In recent weeks the executive has returned to Congress projects promoting two highways in the Peruvian Amazon, two other projects under consideration that are being vigorously opposed by environmental and indigenous organisations, and a fifth paralysed pending consultation with the representatives of affected indigenous peoples. Such conflicts reflect different visions of development in the rainforest, and their outcomes will contribute to determining its future.

As previously reported in this newsletter, in the days preceding the first round of presidential elections Congress approved two highway projects crossing the Peruvian Amazon to Brazil, one from the city of Pucallpa in Ucayali region to Cruzeiro Do Sul in Brazil and the other the Central Oceanic Highway which would connect the Lima, Junín and Ucayali regions and link up with the proposed highway to Brazil.

Both highways were opposed by indigenous and environmental organisations and by various government agencies because they had not been approved by the appropriate authorities or consulted with the affected populations, and because of their negative environmental and human rights impacts. The first proposed law was returned to Congress with observations from the executive at the end of June and the second received similar treatment on 12 July. Congress will now have to decide whether to insist on their proclamation or discard them. This will now fall to the new Congress inaugurated on 28 July.

Refusing to be dissuaded and five years after it was presented to Congress, the congressional committee on transport and communications has approved a proposal to build a road in Requena province that would cross the Jenaro Herrera and Colonia Angamos districts in the Loreto region. The national ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo) and a coalition of indigenous and environmental rights organisations are seeking to prevent Congress from approving the proposal because the road would cross the Yavarí Mirim reserve for indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation and generate negative social and environmental impacts. It would also impact an area in Brazil which has the world’s largest number of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation.

The proposed road is already under construction by the Loreto regional government which reported in January that 18 kilometres had been completed. This is despite the fact that, according to the organisation Cuencas Sagradas, “the road project does not have completed and approved technical studies nor environmental certification nor authorisation to clear forest coverage”. In other words, the proposed law is intended to legalise a road that is already under construction by a regional government and lacks the approval of the relevant technical, environmental and social authorities.

Meanwhile, in the Amazonas region the leaders of the ODECOFROC and ORPIAN-P indigenous organisations are accusing the Ministry of Culture of having violated the principles of good faith, transparency, flexibility and respect for different cultures by failing to implement free, prior and informed consent by the indigenous peoples of the Nieva and El Cenepa districts during the approval of the Urakusa to Huampami road.

Finally, the Peruvian Environmental Law Society has prepared a series of podcasts to illustrate the impact of road construction in the Peruvian Amazon, highlighting, amongst others, the road from Bellavista to El Estrecho via Mazán and Salvador which would connect Peru with the Colombian Amazon. This will affect indigenous territories and protected areas in the Loreto region. They conclude that the lack of planning, the noncompliance with environmental norms, the haste to approve projects, and the apparent ignorance of the pertinent regulations are some of the factors explaining this situation.

For some, roads are seen as a means to connect and develop the Amazon region, both internally and with the outside world, in order to facilitate the extraction and exploitation of its natural resources. For others, in the absence of an effective state presence and the implementation of relevant laws and regulations, roads open the way to human rights abuses, environmental destruction, illegal mining, logging and drug- and people-trafficking.

The outcomes of conflicts between different interests and actors over road construction will play a large part in determining the future of the Amazon rain forest and its climate impacts in the entire South American region.