On 21 July, an authoritative panel of civil society advocates and mining and economy experts tackled the crucial subject of future orientations in mining policy in a virtual event entitled ‘Mining and the Environment: the Challenges for the New Government’. The panel members were Mirta Villanueva, director of Grufides; David Velazco, director of FEDEPAZ; José de Echave, co-founder of Cooperacción and former vice-minister of the environment; Pedro Francke, economist from the PUCP and Pedro Castillo’s economic advisor; and Ruth Luque, elected congresswoman for Juntos por el Perú.

The panellists addressed the issue of the impact of socio-economic conflicts on local communities and the need to find a different approach to mining, one that provides for sustainable and equitable development.

The panel’s analysis of the roots of social conflict emphasized:

  • the erosion of trust through successive governments’ mishandling of the management of environmental and social repercussions of mining projects
  • the constant lack of true consultation
  • governments’ preparedness to give priority to mining investment without regard to local communities
  • the continued use of the police in response to social protest and the criminalisation of community leaders
  • the growth of illegal mining
  • the seriousness of environmental damage.

The panel argued that policy needs to be one of balanced human development (desarrollo humano equilibrado), in which mining revenues and employment creation are not the only aims, but where mining goes hand-in-hand with policy proposals geared towards inclusive, human and sustainable development. Nor can mining development be allowed to conflict with other key priorities, such as protecting the environment and promotion of gender equality. The new government, it was argued, also needs to re-evaluate how environmental permits are granted and make major changes to how consultation is carried out.

Fresh policies need to include those governing the issuing of land grants and permits, the mechanisms for the supervision of concessions granted, legal provisions to protect victims in the handling of social protest, effective control over illegal mining, the protection of human rights defenders – and tax reform. Given the rise in the copper price this year, the panel agreed that this last measure is key in promoting a more equitable distribution of the benefits from mining.

In conclusion, the moderator stressed the need for stronger institutions and different and more effective public policies, but that it was also important that civil society organises itself to strengthen its own capacities and to take ownership of proposals that address the challenges of ensuring a more sustainable future.

To hear the presentation, see here.

To read the report, see here.