Last week’s attempts by members of Congress to elect a new Constitutional Tribunal (TC) ended in disarray, with the three leading candidates receiving less than the required number of votes and the whole process left in question following a judicial resolution ordering Congress to desist from voting due to irregularities of procedure.

The Congress had programmed 7 and 8 of July for the election of six new members of the seven-member TC. However, a judge had ordered the proceedings to be scrapped because of improprieties in the way in which candidates had been short-listed.

Initially, Congress had decided to ignore the judicial ruling, but it became clear that individual members of Congress would be committing common crimes (for which they would lack immunity from prosecution) if they pushed ahead with the ratification of candidates.

The first three candidates to be considered – those who had received more points than any others in the pre-selection – failed to win the support of the two-thirds of Congress required for ratification. One only received six votes. Three parliamentary blocks – the Frente Amplio, the Partido Morado and FREPAP – refused to take part in the election, arguing that the whole process was illegal. Some members belonging to Acción Popular and the Alianza por el Progreso refused to toe their respective party lines.

The congressional session on 8 July had to be suspended, with the announcement that it would be renewed this coming week, on 13 July. However, as we went to press, there were signs that the whole effort by the outgoing Congress to select TC members might have to be jettisoned.

A majority of parties in Congress, mainly on the right, had seen the election of a new TC as a way of increasing their political muscle going forward, in view of a likely Castillo presidency. The TC is the ultimate arbiter in Peru of what is constitutional and what is not.

The outgoing TC has played a critical role in the last few years in resolving discrepancies between the executive and legislature and in voting down laws which violate constitutional norms. On balance, it has tended to favour the executive rather than the Congress in which the right-wing fujimorista party, Fuerza Popular, enjoyed a majority of seats following the 2016 elections.

Even though the terms of most members of the existing TC have expired, the Congress repeatedly failed to appoint replacements and, months back, announced it was cancelling the idea altogether. However, when it became clear that Castillo was likely to become president, a group of members were determined to push ahead in the last few weeks in appointing new members who they believe would back their specific interests.

The objective became clear: if the present Congress fails to elect new TC members, this would fall to the new Congress to accomplish, and until a new TC is appointed, its outgoing members remain in office.

The judicial ruling by Judge Soledad Blácido Báez responded to a claim made by the former dean of the Lima Bar Association, Walter Ayala. For its part lawyers for the Congress have appealed against the ruling saying that it contradicts the principle of separation of powers. Various members of Congress have threatened Blácido with legal reprisals.

According to Congresswoman Rocío Silva Santisteban (Frente Amplio), “to my mind this process has been a process that has lacked transparency, one of tremendous obscurity (…) there are interests [involved] not of the Congress as a Congress, but interests of specific parliamentary blocks and members of Congress with links to persons, companies, universities involved in cases that will go to the TC”.

In the view of the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL) the TC is a fundamental juridical organ and that therefore the appointment of its members should be rigorous and comply with all the necessary formalities; above all “it should guarantee the election of upstanding candidates who guarantee the rule of law” and for that reason “we need a TC to defend democracy”.

The IDL makes the point that if the Congress fails to heed the judicial bar on proceeding with appointments, any of the people it elects would lack the legal authority to carry out their role.