On 6 July, the London-based Catholic development agency, Cafod, published its latest report highlighting the situation for land and environmental defenders in Latin America across six countries: Brazil, Peru, Bolivia, Colombia, Honduras and El Salvador. The research shows six key and interrelated issues facing land and environmental defenders. These form a pattern of abuse across the region, usually affecting already under-represented groups – indigenous, Afro-descendant and campesino communities, and particularly women. They are:

  1. Threats and attacks that are intrinsically linked to unequal control over and access to land and natural resources.
  2. The hostile environment in which Human Rights Defenders (HRDs) operate with civic space restricted, especially for communities seeking to contribute to decisions that affect them.
  3. The failure of state authorities to protect HRDs from harm, in view of a limited state presence on the ground, widespread corruption, and the prevalence of impunity.
  4. Stigmatisation and criminalisation by states as well as business interests against HRDs.
  5. Increased risks given the COVID-19 pandemic and the tendency of states to prioritise extractive industries to encourage economic recovery.
  6. Corporate activity, underpinned by state economic models that strongly favour the expansion of agribusiness, mining and big infrastructure projects.

In Peru, the report highlights the environmental and social impact of mining activities and the lack of effective participation and information available to communities, making it difficult for these to make informed choices and exercise voice in decision-making. It highlights the cases of Tintaya/Antapaccay in Cuzco region (Glencore) and Tía María in Arequipa (Southern Peru Copper). Both demonstrate the misuse of the justice system to criminalise HRDs, often dragging out court cases that can last for years and making it difficult for HRDs to defend their rights.

The report contains recommendations to enable HRDs to operate freely and safely, including “calls for action to protect HRDs from the attacks they face, and to tackle the drivers of this abuse – powerful political and economic forces profiting from their land, water and forests, and models of development that lead to environmental destruction, climate change and human rights abuses”. There are also specific recommendations addressed to the UK government, EU authorities and those of EU members states, Latin American government, as well as to businessmen and investors.

For the full report see here.

For an executive summary see here.