After fifty years of oil extraction and environmental destruction in the northern Peruvian Amazon the Peruvian state is still attempting to enforce regulations to oblige those companies responsible to undertake environmental remediation. There are currently two instances of this, the first relating to Argentine-owned Pluspetrol, the second to the state company Petroperú.

Both illustrate the reluctance of oil companies – whether private or state-owned – to accept responsibility for remediating the environmental damage caused by their activities. They also reveal the weaknesses in both the environmental regulations and in the capacity of the state to enforce its rulings.

In 2015 when Pluspetrol registered for tax purposes in The Netherlands, it relinquished its oil extraction contract in Block 192. At the time, it had not had its close-out plan approved by the environmental authorities. Five years later, when the company was terminating its extraction contract on the neighbouring Block 8, it announced that it was liquidating its subsidiary company operating the two blocks, Pluspetrol Norte. This followed continuous litigation, demands for international arbitration and refusals to comply with rulings by OEFA, the state environmental monitoring and evaluation agency. The liquidation of Pluspetrol Norte appears to be yet another manoeuvre to evade its responsibilities for remediating the environmental damages generated.

In view of Pluspetrol’s efforts to avoid assuming this responsibility, the Ombudsman (Defensoría del Pueblo) issued a communiqué on 25 February urging the state to take the necessary measures to prevent Pluspetrol using the liquidation of its subsidiary as a means to avoid its responsibilities for remediation. To do so, it said “would violate the rights to a balanced environment, life and health.”

The company has been convicted of 245 environmental infractions and faces fines totaling US$2.9 million, not counting those levied for refusing to comply with orders from the environmental authorities.

The Ombudsman recommended that both the Ministries of Health and Energy and Mines evaluate possible new measures to ensure effective presentation and implementation of environmental remediation plans when oil operations are closed down.

The second case, involves the state company Petroperú, operator of the Northern Peruvian Oil Pipeline. OEFA’s Appeals Tribunal has confirmed the ruling requiring the company immediately to carry out the environmental rehabilitation plan to repair the flotation canal in Section I of the pipeline which has produced 16 oil spills affecting neighbouring indigenous communities between 2014 and 2019. (Jorge A. Toledo Ocampo in ‘The North Peruvian oil pipline and its future’ notes “The terrain in Section I, between Stations Nos. 1 and 5, except for a segment of about 25 kilometers, is mainly low-lying jungle, with swamps covered by water over most of the year. Here, the pipes were laid using barges, on a flotation canal”). Petroperú now has 18 months to develop and implement the remediation plan.

This section of the pipeline extends over 306 kilometers in Loreto region. OEFA has determined that sediment in the flotation canal contains concentrations of hydrocarbons exceeding 15,000mg/kg when the natural values in the area do not exceed 50mg/kg and international standards state that they should not exceed 500mg/kg.