A court in Lima has reversed a fine of US$35 million imposed on Tamshiyacu Cacao in 2020 by the environmental watchdog OEFA for the illegal felling of over 2,000 hectares of virgin forest. Declaring the original verdict arbitrary, the judge ruled the company free to continue its cultivation of cacao, in full respect for the environment.

The Peruvian Society of Environmental Law (SPDA) commented that the ruling reflects the lack of understanding by judges of contentious cases of constitutional and administrative law. Although the judgement suspends the original verdict, OEFA is likely to ratify the original fine. However, this would not necessarily be the end of the affair; Tamshiyacu could still present the judiciary with a further preventive measure.

In December, the appeal court of Iquitos reversed an 8-year prison sentence and 15 million soles (approximately US$4 million) fine for the former director of the company, Rubén Antonio Espinoza. The prosecutors of Loreto and of the Ministry of the Environment have lodged an appeal for annulment in Lima.

Tamshiyacu was originally founded by the controversial Czech entrepreneur Denis Melka who left Peru when accused of the deforestation of 13,000 hectares by his enterprise Cacao Peru Norte SAC.

SPDA has also investigated the illegal purchase and clear-felling of 2,800 hectares of forest in Loreto and Ucayali over the last 5 years for agricultural enterprises run by the Menonites, a religious sect of colonists originally from Europe who migrated from Bolivia. According to the eminent Peruvian forestry engineer Marc Dourojeanni, the Menonites run unsustainable agri-businesses yet claim to be organic and ecological farmers.