With just over two months to go to the first round of elections, the opinion polls are beginning to make some sense out of who has a chance of making it to a second round and who are the no-hopers. Of course, if past elections are a guide, there is still plenty of time for dark horses to make the running. Remember 2011 when Ollanta Humala proved that the last can be first or, even more memorably, 1990 when Alberto Fujimori broke all normal electoral paradigms.

The two main polling agencies appear to be the Instituto de Estudios Peruanos (for the La República newspaper) and Ipsos (for El Comercio). Though they portray slightly different results in terms of front-runners, both coincide in putting George Forsyth (see profile) slightly ahead of a bunch of candidates who (given the range of statistical error) are all running neck and neck: Verónika Mendoza (see profile), Keiko Fujimori, Julio Guzmán (see profile), Daniel Urresti, and Yonhi Lescano. They also concur on the fact that most potential voters still have little idea of who they will eventually vote for, or are reluctant to identify their preferred candidate.

That the ‘don’t knows/won’t says’ are so numerous is hardly surprising. For most Peruvians, the Covid-19 pandemic which has surged back again in recent weeks, means that – whether for health reasons, economic reasons or a combination of the two – they have other things on their minds right now. The sheer number of presidential candidates also makes for confusion, especially when people are asked, without having the candidates’ names read out to them, whom they would opt for. And another reason is that most candidates have, up to now, tried to avoid saying much what they stand for; ideology seems to be a dirty word.

What is abundantly clear in this otherwise foggy prognosis is that no presidential candidate will win outright on the first round. The immediate objective for all of them, therefore, is to qualify for the second eliminating round in which the two candidates with most votes will compete against one another.

Again, if past elections are a guide here, the eventual winner is likely to be the ‘mal menor’, or the lesser of two evils. This was the case in 2006 when Alan García beat Ollanta Humala by a very narrow margin, successfully portraying Humala as being from the extreme left. It was the case in 2011 when Humala also narrowly beat Keiko Fujimori, managing to rally the anti-Fujimori vote behind him. It again played a role in 2016 when, for similar reasons, Pedro Pablo Kuczynski rallied anti-Keiko sentiments to win, once again, by the slimmest of margins.

This is a system that tends to favour centrist candidates. In the coming elections, there are number of candidates who seek to establish themselves in the centre ground. They include Guzmán whose Partido Morado consciously seeks to pose as being neither ‘left’ nor ‘right’. Also in this category falls Lescano, whose Acción Popular party has long sought to rally voters around a very diffuse ideology of ‘Peruvianess’ (Peru as a doctrine, as Fernando Belaunde liked to put it). Forsyth also fits in here, a candidate who has so far done his best to avoid ideological classification.

Even on the left and on the right, candidates are aware of the need to appeal to a wide constituency and minimise electors’ sense of antipathy. Both Mendoza and Fujimori have sought to widen their acceptability in recent weeks, finesse their public image, and look beyond their narrow bases of militant support.

All candidates will be aware of the characteristics of the Peruvian electorate. At least half of all voters are from economically disadvantaged sectors (belonging to socioeconomic groups D and E), and while Lima represents about a third of the voting country, two-thirds live outside the capital. A majority of voters are also highly distrustful of the workings of democratic institutions and suspicious about the motives and intentions of politicians. The ability of candidates convincingly to distance themselves from the dirty politics which have been so obvious in the last five years will be an important plus.

Beyond this, all is blindingly unclear.