On 23 October, the minister of energy and mines, Miguel Incháustegui, installed a new and expanded multi-sector working group to discuss where and how to move ahead. The quest to build some consensus over the future of mining development is commendable, not least because of the challenges it presents. The Peru Support Group provided a small input into the initiation of Rimay last November with the presentation of its report on dialogue and human rights in the mining sector.
The Peru 2030 Mining Vision was developed between September 2018 and February 2019 when Incháustegui was vice-minister for mining. It was coordinated by Rimay (the name given to the Ministry of Energy and Mines` Centro de Convergencia y Buenas Prácticas Minero Energéticas) and supported by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB). Rimay involved a multi-stakeholder group of government officials and representatives from the private sector, academia, and civil society.
In its summary, the Vision states that “By 2030, mining in Peru [will be] inclusive, socially, environmentally and territorially integrated, within a framework of good governance and sustainable development framework. It [will be] consolidated as a competitive and innovative activity and be valued by all of society”.
To this end, two phases were envisioned. One involved setting up technical working groups to provide concrete content to the general ideas on social inclusiveness, environmental sustainability, economic competitiveness and good governance contained in the Vision. The other was to develop multi-stakeholder and regionalised versions in selected mining territories.
A series of events delayed the inauguration of the second phase which began last week with the inauguration of the expanded working group.
Two mining regions will now be selected to replicate the national vision building exercise of phase one. Moquegua, Cajamarca, Ancash, and the southern corridor (which runs through Apurímac, Cuzco and Arequipa) are being considered.
That mining is important and will continue to be so is a shared view. However, two opposing criteria will be used to narrow down the choice to just two regions: the potential for stakeholder collaboration needed to ensure some degree of success; and the potential for conflict to test the capacity of the Vision to engage and bring together actors that today express strong disagreements.
Maybe choosing one region meeting each criterion is the way to go.
In the meantime, methodological questions arise as to how to identify the regional actors that will participate, and how to guarantee a truly multi-stakeholder and participatory exercise that is, at once, both efficient and deliverable.
The Rimay initiative espoused by Incháustegui is ambitious and bold. Agreement on a shared national vision took time and commitment because of the different starting points and viewpoints of the diverse actors involved. Such a vision may be even harder to realise at the regional level, especially in those parts of the country where companies, local authorities and social organisations have already clashed over mining projects.
It is worth recalling that conflicts around mining constitute the majority of all conflicts in Peru, and they take place in situations of polarisation where dialogue may prove highly problematic. But it is because the Rimay is so challenging that it is such a commendable project.
Recent Comments