The deadline for political reforms passed on 28 September; not much is left standing of the list of recommendations made last year that will apply to next year’s general elections. According to Fernando Tuesta, the chair of the high-level commission appointed to advise on political and electoral reforms, what was missing was the political will to apply the reform package.

A key point that the Congress resisted was the ending of the preferential vote system. Under the current system, voters are free to select from lists of candidates for Congress, a system that encourages dispersion of votes and weakens the party system. A closed list system would mean choosing members of Congress from a pre-selected party list in accordance with the total number of votes achieved by that party.

According to Tuesta, the preferential vote system is one of the reasons for the deplorable level of most of those elected to Congress in recent decades. The system has been in place since 1985. Getting rid of this system was a priority for Transparencia, the local affiliate of Transparency International.

Ending the preferential vote was supported by the Partido Morado, Frepap and the Frente Amplio, but opposed by Acción Popular, Alianza para el Progreso, Podemos Perú and Fuerza Popular. It was rejected outright by a majority on the committee of party representatives (junta de portavoces) in Congress and so not debated in a plenary session.

Failure to pass this meant that a further reform, approved by Congress, will mean little or nothing: a law that guarantees gender parity (paridad y alternancia). To ensure parity would involve constructing closed party lists in which, for example, if the first candidate on the list is male, the second would have to be female, the third male and so forth. Where voters can vote for whoever they wish on party lists, there will be no guarantee of parity.

The reform that would introduce the holding of open primaries to select party candidates has had to be abandoned because of the Covid-19 pandemic. These were supposed to be held simultaneously and under the supervision of the electoral authorities. The idea was to enhance internal democracy within parties. Candidates can thus be handpicked by select internal committees of party leaders. The primary system will apply to the next regional and municipal elections in 2022.

Another element in the reform package concerned party funding. Here, Congress only approved the suspension of parties committing grave infractions of the law (for twelve months), not the cancelling of their registration which had been included in the original bill.

Still, some reforms will see the light of day:

  • A reform that has passed on to the statute book and will apply to the forthcoming elections concerns Peruvians living abroad who will have, henceforth, two representatives in Congress.
  • The electoral authorities will exercise greater supervision of parties’ bank accounts.
  • Candidates with criminal records will be blocked from standing for election.

But as in most things, the efficacy of the changes introduced to the political and electoral system will be only as effective as the way they are implemented and enforced.