Over the last week, the Inter-American Commission of Human Rights (IACHR) held its 177th period of sessions, all virtually. Two of these hearings were petitioned by indigenous organisations and covered increasingly pressing issues affecting indigenous rights: (i) the situation of human rights defenders in the Peruvian Amazon and (ii) the right to free, prior and informed consent in Latin America, with special focus on Peru, Colombia, Mexico and Brazil.
- Human rights of indigenous peoples in the Peruvian Amazonia
On 6 October, the hearing entitled “Human Rights of Indigenous People in the Peruvian Amazonia” took place, with the presence of indigenous leaders from Shipibo-Conibo, Kakataibo and Asháninka communities, which have been the target of attacks, threats and intimidation as a result of their struggle to defend their environment and ancestral lands. As reported by the PSG on previous occasions, environmental defenders are increasingly under threat, with four killings taking place in 2020 so far. According to the petitioners, these communities have witnessed the killing of eleven indigenous human rights defenders, two during the Covid-19 emergency.
One of the key issues highlighted by all petitioners is the link between corruption and the violation of the rights of indigenous communities, arising from the “structural impunity that guarantees these violations”. Leaders talked of continuous threats faced by drug trafficking, land grabbing and illegal logging.
The president of the regional section of the Interethnic Association for the Development of the Peruvian Rainforest in Ucayali (ORPIO, Aidesep), Berlin Diques, has been the target of recent threats. During the hearing, he stated that ORPIO staff had also been targeted and that recently one of his colleagues suffered a gun wound, and that the following day he had received a threatening letter warning him that his life was in peril. At the hearing, he voiced the struggles that communities were facing against “big economic interests” as the western world seeks to profit from their territories.
An Asháninka representative, Diana Rios, from the community of Alto Tamaya-Saweto, recalled the killing of her father and three other leaders in 2014, allegedly by illegal loggers and land traffickers. Six years later, no-one had been found responsible or brought to justice. She says that “to date, the murderers are still free, and we continue to be threatened by the mafia and corruption, with no protection from the state”.
The representative of the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL), Alvaro Márquez, emphasised the lack of state presence and the prevalence of corruption as being among the most important structural problems leading to human rights violations and killings. He declared that the state was incapable of punishing perpetrators or providing established guarantees that prevent crimes being repeated.
Peruvian government representatives acknowledged the role of corruption in perpetuating impunity and pointed at the existence of 42 regional prosecutors’ offices in investigating corruption charges, with three offices based in Ucayali, four in Huánuco and three in Pasco.
They highlighted steps to put in place protection measures, as laid out by the Protocol for the Protection of Human Rights Defenders. They said they have received fifteen requests for intervention, eight of which have been taken up and are in process. Five came from environmental and indigenous people’s defenders, including some of the leaders present at the hearing.
Members of the IACHR then stressed their concern for the ongoing risks facing indigenous communities and their leaders. They pointed to the lack of prevention measures and asked whether indigenous communities had been involved in the elaboration of the Protection Protocol. Commissioner Margarette May Macaulay said: “I’m very sad and upset to hear this all over again”. After years in the job she keeps hearing the same stories. “When is it going to stop?” she asked.
Commission members suggested the creation of a virtual round table to discuss the role of businesses and human rights, offering advice and involvement. Although the National Plan of Action on Business and Human Rights is still being developed, they argued that dialogue was needed between all stakeholders if the risks faced by indigenous communities and their leaders are to be mitigated.
They also pointed to problems of corruption and political capture. They referred to a IACHR report published last year that could be used as a model for the development of sets of standards.
Towards the end of the hearing, indigenous representatives challenged the version of state officials saying that no proper protection is provided and that this is urgently required if more killing of leaders is to be averted. They raised the urgent need to give priority to land titling. They claimed that the Protocol lacks both sufficient budget and the commitment to make it effective. They pointed out that the National Action Plan on Business and Human Rights won’t deal with illegal economic activities such as land grabbing, illegal logging and drug trafficking.
Following the hearing, indigenous leaders expressed frustration at the lack of seriousness shown by the state authorities. They claimed the authorities had lied to the IAHRC to make them think that environmental defenders are being properly protected.
- Prior consultation and the right to free, prior and informed consent
The second hearing was held on 9 October. This dealt with the ongoing problem of effective implementation of prior consultation and informed consent. Although the theme covered the whole of Latin America, discussion focused on the situation for indigenous communities in Mexico, Peru, Brazil and Colombia.
More than 39 civil society and indigenous organisations took part. Vanessa Cueto, president of DAR (Derechos, Ambiente y Recursos Naturales), and Lizardo Cauper, president of AIDESEP, represented Peru during the session. All representatives agreed on the lack of effective consultation mechanisms and that states continue to sidestep legal procedures in granting concessions to economic interests.
In Peru, Cueto and Cauper referred to two emblematic cases in which the risks to ancestral lands and the environment still prevail in spite of the existence of a normative framework that recognises the right to prior consultation. Cauper mentioned Block 58, in Cuzco region, where indigenous communities have not been consulted despite the approval of three different instruments for environmental management, an environmental impact assessment (EIA) and a further modification to its EIA. He said the Peruvian government must recognise the need to ensure that administrative measures that impact on indigenous rights should involve proper consultation.
He also referred to the Waterways (Hidrovías) project: despite an agreement reached through consultation, none of the commitments had been fulfilled. The project has been found to contain serious flaws with its environmental certification and, to date, communities lack accurate information about the real impact of dredging on their communities and environment. They demand a binding timeline to ensure that all agreements are met.
Cueto talked of the current context of economic recovery and how this threatens environmental standards and fiscal oversight. She noted with concern proposals to short-cut project approval, including the holding of virtual consultations and reductions in the time allotted to these. She says that the Peruvian government only sees the right to prior consultation as a formality and that, where consultation takes place, agreements are vitiated by state incapacity to monitor implementation.
Recent Comments