By Thomas Pegram

The power of the media is rarely exercised with more impact than during elections. The seriousness with which politicians court media executives reflects the media’s potential to make or break the ambitions of would-be political kingpins. The union of political advantage with commercial interest, often in the form of lucrative advertising campaigns, is a cause of concern in many countries, but in few places does the charge of media bias resonate as strongly as in Peru.

In part, widespread distrust of the media in Peru stems from the country’s recent past. The manipulation of the media was a defining characteristic of the Fujimori government, arguably the first in Latin America to appreciate fully the power of systematically bankrolling the media to further its own political ends. Six years since the reinstatement of democracy, newspapers and television channels enjoy an unprecedented freedom. However, media coverage during the 2006 elections has thrown the spotlight anew onto the interests and agendas that drive an elitist and largely unaccountable media in Peruvian politics.

The object of controversy: presidential candidate Ollanta Humala. A political outsider, ex-military officer and advocate of an elite-baiting nationalist discourse, Humala has proven a potent political force among Peru’s marginalised poor. In turn, reflecting the experience of other ‘leftist’ leaders in the region, he has provoked an increasingly nervous Peruvian elite. Nowhere has the resulting antipathy been played out more openly than in the media. The negative coverage of Humala is widely regarded as unprecedented – even exceeding the hostilities directed toward Fujimori in 1990 – leading to calls for more balanced reporting and regulation.

According to the NGO Transparencia, between 10 January and 10 February 2006, Humala received more than 2,500 mentions in the mainstream press, accounting for 33.24% of all coverage of the three main Presidential candidates; Humala, Alan García of APRA and Lourdes Flores of the National Unity party (UN). However, according to the same NGO, 69% of publicity directed toward Humala was focused solely on accusations, denouncements and rebuttals. This contrasted starkly with similar coverage of the other two candidates, Flores (8%) and García (8%).

Without doubt, Humala and close associates have proven a veritable goldmine of scandal. In the print media, dailies such as La Republica, have led a vocal campaign against Humala’s candidacy. A recent controversy, dubbed “dedocracia,” or ‘finger-ocracy,’ surrounds a series of allegations claiming that Humala hand-picked party congressional candidates, rather than respecting the internal party vote. Extensive coverage has also been given to Humala’s suspect human rights record and alleged ties to Montesinos. Humala has been personally implicated in human rights crimes during his time serving as an army captain in the jungle region of Madre Mía in 1992.

A further source of conflict has been the outspoken comments of various family members. His brother Antauro, himself no stranger to controversy, has caused consternation in calling for the nationalisation of the media and the shooting of politicians. Negative coverage has also dominated television, with the owner of Peru’s Panamericana TV station, Genaro Delgado Parker, widely rumoured to be the invisible hand behind the Madre Mía scandals.

In light of this, claims of an ‘Everybody against Humala’ strategy have persisted. The widespread endorsement given to centre-right candidate Flores throughout the first round has transferred, though in more mute tones, to the centre-left candidate García in the second. Beyond the immediate issue of media bias surrounding the elections, there is little doubt that market structures and commercial interests have conspired against democratization of media access in Peru, with the majority of newspapers and television channels remaining under the control of a small group of private interests.
As with most countries, it is difficult to find out who owns the media in Peru and their political connections even more so. Though, on occasion, such relationships do come to light. For example, García’s Presidential running mate, Lourdes Mendoza del Solar, happens also to be the daughter of Enrique “Kiko” Mendoza, owner of an Arequipa newspaper and Canal 8, a television channel with coverage throughout the south of Peru.

The impact of the media on public opinion is real though not easy to gauge. Following a surge in the polls in April 2006, Humala comfortably won the first round with 30.6% – though far from the majority necessary for outright victory. The build-up to the second round has seen the opposition vote unify around García and negative coverage intensify. Humala’s share in the polls slipped from 8% behind García in mid-April to a virtually insurmountable 22% at the close of May. The negative media backdrop has almost certainly played a role in this steady descent. The poorest regions in Peru, those that overwhelmingly voted for Humala in the first round, appear to have been unswayed by the accusations against Humala, regarding them as part of a smear campaign by the rich and powerful. But the effect of negative publicity is more discernible among potential undecided or protest voters who increasingly regard Humala as too radical and violent.

Whatever the results of the election, questions surrounding the role of the media in the final outcome will remain. The focus on personalities and scandals rather than policy issues reflects a wider trend in Peru’s mass media. Even ‘serious’ dailies like El Comercio devote, on average, 28% of their coverage to sports and entertainment. Radio is the exception to the rule. Due to the number of stations competing for listeners and their visibility in communities throughout Peru, radio is widely regarded as independent and an important resource to local political activity. There is also a growing online community of bloggers and independent media outlets. But the influence of these arenas of public debate pales in comparison to the titans of national television. Democratisation of the media, thus far politically ignored, remains a pressing challenge for Peruvian democracy.