June marked the fifth anniversary of one of the most violent clashes in recent Peruvian history. On 5 June 2009, demonstrators and police were killed when police clashed with indigenous people protesting against the imposition of two legislative decrees – 1090 and 1064 – that authorised exploitation of natural resources on ancestral land. By the end of that day, 23 police officers and 10 civilians had lost their lives and hundreds lay wounded in what is widely regarded as one of the most catastrophic operations in the history of the Peruvian police.
Five years later, judicial proceedings grind slowly on, with the first trial beginning in June 2014 against 24 indigenous peoples from two ethnic groups, the Wampi and Awajún, accused of killing ten police officers. The trial in Bagua province has been plagued by delays due to the remote location of the proceedings, combined with the challenge of guaranteeing due process to the defendants. The trial has highlighted the failings of a justice system ill-equipped to provide basic guarantees such as native language translation.
This Bagua trial has become one of the highest profile judicial processes. However, four others are also at various stages of pre-trial investigation: six police officers charged for injuring and murdering civilians at the roadblock that day; a group of indigenous individuals accused of killing unarmed policemen at Station No. 6 Petroperu; those accused of the disappearance of Police Major Felipe Bazan (whose body has not been recovered); and the prosecution of four high-level police officials, including the former director-general of police, José Armando Sánchez Farfán, for the injuring and murder of civilians.
As various commentators have pointed out, no politician has yet been censured or held to account for Bagua. The Institute of Legal Defence (IDL) requested that the role of Mercedes Cabanillas, then minister of the interior, be investigated as part of the case against Sánchez Farfán. Cabanillas is alleged to have given the order to attack the protestors. However, the court did not respond to this request and Cabanillas, a leading member of the APRA party, is currently to be called only as a witness.
Amidst heated political recriminations, hard questions remain regarding responsibility along the chain of command on that day. Business interests have been particularly vocal in placing the blame at the door of agents provocateurs in civil society. In a controversial editorial, El Comercio launched a broadside against the NGO AIDESEP and the Human Rights Ombudsman’s office, alleging that they had misled local communities and had fanned the flames which led to the confrontation. This charge has been robustly rejected by both organisations. Evidence has recently emerged, courtesy of WikiLeaks, that suggests that the then-US Ambassador to Peru was instrumental in encouraging the government to use force on the protestors.
The Baguazo (as it is known) has thrown the spotlight once again on Peru’s historical neglect of the Amazon and discrimination against the peoples who live there. The current administration’s introduction of a prior consultation law in 2011 was hailed as an important step forward in this respect. However, facing concerted business opposition, the effect of law has since been watered down by a series of administrative regulations.
Five years on, the country is still struggling to strike the balance between observing the rights of indigenous peoples and the demands of the investor community.
Recent Comments