The last month has produced a number of somewhat positive results in regard to Peru’s approach to the environment and extractives-related issues.

  • First, the Organización de Evaluación y Fiscalización del Ambiente (OEFA), an agency of the Ministry of the Environment (MINAM), is moving to set up new specialised courts for the mining, energy and fishing industries, to expedite cases of alleged environmental abuse.
  • Second, the same body has increased the number of fines it has imposed on companies for excessive omissions.
  • Third – and significant in the human rights arena – on December 18, the Supreme Court of Cajamarca overturned the sentence passed on the Chaupe family by a lower court. The family – and centrally, Maxima Acuna del Chaupe, or the ‘Lady of the Lagunas’ as she has become known – has waged a two-year battle against the Yanacocha Mining Company over the company’s proposed Conga project. Family members had been convicted of land usurpation in the course of the struggle against Conga. Maxima and three members of her family had been sentenced to two years eight months in prison and to payment of a $2,000 fine. Further charges and the company’s appeal against this latest ruling are still pending.

The PSG cannot but feel that these events are more than just straws in the wind. The trend towards weakening the authority of MINAM has continued. The ministry has been under-resourced since its creation and suffers from a weak institutional structure. Its authority was gravely weakened by the paquetazo of last July (see PSG ‘Investment versus the environment: the need for a new approach’, 31 July 2014) and the passing of a new law in January aimed at simplifying the processes by which environmental impact assessments (EIAs) are approved. This legislation does nothing to put adequately resourced systems in place, and while simplification may not itself be a bad thing, there are widespread fears that the ministry’s regulatory remit will be further weakened by shortening of the maximum time it is allowed to consider EIAs.