On 17 June, Congress passed Law No. 32667 modifying Law No. 24166 (of 1985) that created the Colegio de Antropólogos, the officially recognised professional body for anthropologists in Peru. The amendment to the legislation has given rise to bitter criticism both by indigenous peoples as well as members of the academic community.

Those exercising the profession of anthropologist in Peru must now be a member of the Colegio and trained in the formulation, execution, monitoring and evaluation of public policies, development plans, environmental plans, life plans and social and cultural programmes and projects.

This is not an isolated case. Rather, it forms part of a broader legislative trend towards tighter regulation of professions in the social sciences, including initiatives to establish professional associations for political scientists and, more recently, artists.

AIDESEP, the organisation representing indigenous peoples, is arguing that the changes will produce disproportionate restrictions on interdisciplinary work and an undue concentration of professional competencies. It also complains that the legislative changes were made without consulting indigenous peoples, the very subjects (or object) of the anthropological profession, in ways that violate their right to autonomy.

AIDESEP is demanding that the law be repealed and the Ministry for Culture should annul the associated regulations. It is also requesting the Colegio not to apply those articles that it considers would lead to exclusion, limit intercultural dialogue and grant a monopoly to the Colegio for the production of knowledge relating to indigenous peoples.

The risk is that indigenous communities will be represented through the signature of a formally accredited professional who may not necessarily understand the historical, social and political realities of territories that are increasingly threatened by organised crime and illegal economies.

In early July, the Department of Sociology at San Marcos University held a forum on the new legislation in which diverse limitations to the legislation were discussed. The forum concluded that the law does not respond to the principal needs of the profession by improving professional conditions or standards.

According to Pablo Sandoval, an anthropologist, the law “creates at least four identifiable risks: it technocratises the teaching and practice of anthropology by subordinating both to the Association’s corporate oversight; it seeks to create a captive and monopolised labour market centred on the signature of a licensed and registered anthropologist; it excludes indigenous peoples from legal decisions and actions taken on their behalf; and it concentrates the power to license and revoke professional authorisation in the Association without establishing sufficient checks and balances”.

Article 3 makes membership of the Colegio compulsory for the formal practice of anthropology in Peru. However, the law does not define what constitutes professional practice, leaving scope for interpretation by the body itself. This ambiguity could also allow it to interpret university teaching as a form of professional practice and require academic staff to hold professional membership, even though the law neither explicitly authorises nor prohibits such a requirement. The law thus raises questions about university autonomy.

Article 6 requires public and private institutions to involve a registered anthropologist in the design, implementation and evaluation of public policies, development plans, environmental initiatives, along with social and cultural programmes. These must be signed off by a qualified anthropologist professionally registered and authorised by the relevant chapter of the Colegio.