In an historic ruling on 26 January, the Constitutional Bench of the High Court in Lima ruled that the constitution demands that Congress implements free, prior, and informed consent for all legislative measures affecting the rights of indigenous peoples.
This decision, which is definitive and cannot be overruled by the Constitutional Tribunal, comes 31 years after Peru signed International Labour Organisation (ILO) Convention 169; 29 years after it was ratified by Congress; 13 years after the Prior Consultation Law was passed by Congress; and eight years after a law suit was initiated to oblige Congress to respect the country’s international obligations, the constitution and its own legislation.
On 9 August 2016, the National Agrarian Confederation (CNA), one of the two national federations representing highland communities, and the National Organisation of Andean and Amazonian Indigenous Women (ONAMIAP), sued Congress to force it to debate Bill 005-2016/CR. They were supported in this by two NGOs: IDLADS (Environmental Legal Defence and Sustainable Development) and DAR (Rights Environment and Resources).
The bill had been presented by the ex-congressman Marco Arana. It proposed amendments to congressional regulations, calling for it to respect Article 6 of the ILO Convention and the Prior Consultation Law by including procedures for the prior consultation of indigenous peoples over legislative measures affecting their rights.
Ironically, the first and only time that Congress consulted indigenous peoples about legislation affecting their rights was in 2014-2015 when Congress passed the Forestry and Wildlife Law (No. 29763). The executive at the time had consulted on its regulation with indigenous peoples. In the final session of Congress last year (see also article below) this same law was amended by Law No. 31973 without any prior consultation, generating a firestorm of indignation and protest.
In October 2021, Congresswoman Ruth Luque had requested the then leadership in Congress to update Bill 005-2016/CR. It thus became Bill 766/2021-CR and was thereafter sent to the Constitutional Commission for consideration and subsequent debate by the full assembly.
For a full two years the bill languished in the Constitutional Commission. On 5 February, Luque, now president of the Indigenous Peoples and Environment Commission, wrote to the president of Congress calling on him to urge the Constitutional Commission to place the bill on its agenda and to debate its merits.
It remains to be seen whether, after some 30 years of inertia and resistance, Congress will now revise its procedures to incorporate the right to free, prior, and informed consent of indigenous peoples.
Meanwhile, after six months of contentious negotiations, on 27 January, the state agency Perupetro and the Ministry of Energy and Mines (Minem) for the first time signed an agreement involving 86 issues including a compensation fund, in prior consultation with regard to the concession of Block 8 with 21 indigenous communities along the Corrientes and Chambira rivers in Loreto region.
Recent Comments