After six years of negotiations with representatives of indigenous peoples, the government has approved a National Indigenous Peoples and First Nations Policy to 2040, the first of its kind in the region. The policy is intended to be an instrument that orients and articulates state decisions in such a way as to guarantee the effective exercise of the collective rights of around six million Peruvians who identify as indigenous. Only time will tell if it proves truly transformative.
As a multisectoral and binding policy that applies to 40 agencies in 19 ministries, it is hoped that Peru will become a leader in Latin America in the protection of the collective and cultural rights of its indigenous peoples. According to the Ministry of Culture “it represents a landmark in the relationship with historically excluded peoples”.
The central objectives are to:
- guarantee the legal security of traditional collective lands and territories;
- reduce vulnerability in the face of environmental degradation and the impacts of climate change;
- guarantee the protection, recognition and valuation of traditional knowledge, science and technology;
- guarantee the effective and timely exercise of collective rights to participation, consultation and free, prior and informed consent;
- guarantee the rights of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation;
- improve the conditions for the exercise of the rights of indigenous women;
- guarantee the social development of indigenous and First Nations peoples through self-determination;
- guarantee the conditions for the sustainable and solidary economic development of indigenous peoples; and to
- reduce violence, racism and ethno-racial discrimination.
This is an ambitious document which holds out the promise that by 2040 seven of every ten indigenous persons will be fully exercising their collective and culturally informed rights. In this sense, the symbolic value is that, for the first time, the state is attempting to articulate a long-term policy intended specifically for indigenous peoples.
The implementation of these broad policy objectives will not be without difficulties and will require resources, political will and the real and effective presence of the state in often remote areas. However, for the first time, the ministries will not be able to wash their hands from the obligation to respect indigenous rights because “it is not their responsibility”; the policy requires them to coordinate.
Nevertheless, experience in Peru teaches us that coordination without the necessary resources usually becomes “shared bureaucracy”. Whereas this new policy recognises that land titling is fundamental, nowadays the threat does not only come from the lack of documented titles but also from illegal mining, indiscriminate logging and drug trafficking.
Furthermore, one of the most delicate issues is the protection of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. Without an effective state presence – involving doctors, park rangers, territorial control, etc – “protection” is in danger of staying at the level of the diplomatic language used by international organisms. Even if the policy is effectively implemented, the fact that three out of ten indigenous will continue without fully exercising their rights ought to be reason for national disquiet, not celebration.
Some see in the policy a historic opportunity; others suspect that it could be converted into a means of political contention, involving more formal dialogue but little by way of real transformations. Many indigenous demand autonomy and the capacity to decide about their territories, not simply technical assistance and state programmes.
Recent Comments