Two measures aimed at economic development in the Loreto region, one, a highway promoted by the national government and the other the reactivation of logging by the regional government, illustrate the difficulties in achieving consistency of policy between national ministries and regional governments on the one hand and a coherent balance between the objectives of economic development, indigenous rights and environmental conservation on the other.

The national government has approved a budget of 1,481 million soles (US$411 million) to enable the Ministry of Transport to complete the second stage of a proposed highway linking Iquitos with the Colombian border town of Estrecho, a measure prioritised to reactivate the post pandemic economy. The project was declared by Congress in 2011 to be “in the national interest”.

However, environmental and human rights activists are concerned about the environmental and social impacts of the road. Alfonso Malky, technical director for Latin America of the Conservation Strategy Fund (CSF), argues that “the fact that a highway can generate an economic return does not mean that it is appropriate or should be constructed, especially taking into account the environmental costs”.

The CSF estimates that the highway would generate the loss of 15,500 hectares of forest. It will also cross two protected natural areas and forest declared as suitable for selective logging, as well as areas where coca is being cultivated illegally. Furthermore, indigenous leaders claim that construction work is being carried out on their territories without their permission and that the illegal trafficking of timber and wildlife will be encouraged. They fear that conflicts will arise between those communities that believe the road will benefit them and those that believe otherwise.

Transport expert Gustavo Guerra García claims that disorganisation within the transport ministry impedes the evaluation of better options for public works like highways.

The Loreto regional government has now included 169 forest concessions granted between 2003 and 2019 in its economic reactivation plan, of which 37 overlap indigenous territories whose land titles are still being processed, including 22 that are due to be approved as reserves for peoples in voluntary isolation and initial contact.

The regional indigenous federation (ORPIO) has lodged a writ to prevent the regional government from reactivating the concessions and this now awaits a hearing. In response, the regional government’s forestry department has excluded 59 concessions with legal problems from the plan. However, it claims that for the concessions to be annulled the culture ministry in Lima must first define the legal situation of the proposed indigenous reserves. This is a process that takes years.

For their part, both the Ministry of Culture and the Ombudsman’s office (Defensoría del Pueblo) are demanding that the regional government suspend the granting of logging permits. According to the lawyer for the Legal Defence Institute (IDL), Maritza Quispe, “it is crucial that the national government create the reserves for indigenous people in isolation and initial contact and that, while this is proceeding, the regional government suspend the granting of permits, not only for logging but also for oil exploration, and implement protection mechanisms”.

To top all this off, the regional government fears that it may face legal action for compensation from the holders of logging permits and it is now proposing that indigenous communities voluntarily allow loggers who lose their concessions to undertake logging on community lands.

Meanwhile, on a more encouraging note, the national women’s indigenous organisation, ONAMIAP, has announced that the culture ministry has changed its mind about organising virtual consultations with indigenous peoples, a point we raised two weeks ago. The Indigenous Policies Working Group has decided to postpone consultation processes until after the Covid-19 health emergency is over.