Eleven years after the murder of indigenous leaders Edwin Chota Valera, Francisco Pinedo Ramírez, Jorge Ríos Pérez y Leoncio Quintisima Meléndez from the Alto Tamaya Saweto community, justice was finally delivered to their four widows. The leaders were ambushed and assassinated by illegal loggers while travelling to the Apiwtza community in Brazil to coordinate actions in defence of their territories.

In a joint statement, the German, Canadian, Norwegian and UK embassies declared that the case represented an important step in the fight against impunity and recognition of the important role played by indigenous communities in protecting the environment. They argued that the verdict will help strengthen the protection of human rights and environmental defenders.

In recent years some 36 environmental defenders have been assassinated in Peru, and this is the first time that those responsible have been convicted, thus setting a precedent for future cases.

The case has been one of seemingly endless delays. The accused were arraigned in 2019, five years after the incident, and the court in Ucayali convicted José Estrada Huayta, Hugo Soria Flores and the brothers Josimar and Segundo Atachi Felix to 28 years and three months in jail.

However, the appeals court annulled the decision on a technicality. A second trial began in November 2023, and in April 2024 the accused were again convicted and again sentenced to 28 years and three months. Each of the four victims was also awarded 50,000 soles in reparations.

This sentence, in turn, was appealed by both sides. The prosecution requested an increase in the penalty; the families of the victims requested an increase in the amount for reparations; and the accused requested that the sentences be annulled.

Finally, on 25 August the appeals court confirmed the jail sentences for the four accused and increased the reparations to 100,000 soles for each of the four victims. The judges then ordered the capture of the convicted men who did not appear in court and are thought to be seeking refuge across the border in Brazil.

The ambassadors expressed their solidarity with the victims’ families and with all those who work for justice and the defence of the Amazonian rainforest. They highlighted the fact that the sentence had been read both in the Spanish and Ashaninka languages, the latter being spoken in the victims’ community.