The delegation of legislative powers by Congress to the executive has so far resulted in an impasse in the Senate with supporters of Keiko Fujimori seeking to ignore moves by opposition parties questioning whether the Senate can change the substance of the bill received last week from the Chamber of Deputies. Fuerza Popular is more strongly represented in the Senate, although it does not have an absolute majority there.

As we mentioned last week, the debate revolves around the ability to ‘desnaturalizar’ the original bill from the Chamber. The Constitutional Commission chair, Carlos Mesía, a member of FP, sought to add seven additional items to the bill agreed upon in the Chamber. For members of the opposition parties this constituted a substantial change. However, the constitutional amendment that allowed for the restoration of the Senate provides little guidance as to what ‘desnaturalizar’ can be taken to mean.

The opposition parties with Senate seats – the Partido de Bueno Gobierno, Juntos por el Perú, Obras and Ahora Nación – sought a preliminary debate to define whether the upper house can alter the bill received from the lower house. In most bicameral systems, the upper house may amend bills received, but the last word remains with the lower house. This is not the case in Peru. A vote on this ‘point of order’ was carried by six votes to five, but Mesía sought to override this by calling for a second vote, at which point the opposition parties withdrew in protest.

The Constitution Commission had been scheduled to vote on the bill to delegate legislative authority on Thursday15 October, enabling the plenary of the Senate to vote on Monday 19 October. Opposition members of the Senate accused Mesía in acting in an authoritarian and anti-democratic fashion, ignoring majority votes. Mesía has since said that he will not convene a new meeting of the Commission until such time as there is a consensus.

The fate of the powers requested by the executive represent the first major clash between the executive and legislature in the new presidential term. The Congress has delayed in approving these. The Chamber agreed only on a whittled down list of legislative items, limiting these to matters strictly relating to the crackdown on organised crime and measures to offset the effects of the El Niño phenomenon. Mesía sought to resurrect a number of items on the executive’s original list, mainly relating to the role of the military in combatting organised crime.

For much of the last decade, FP and its right-wing allies in Congress sought to use their power to harass the executive, notably the short-lived left-wing administration of Pedro Castillo (2021-22). They repeatedly censured ministers (forcing them to resign) and impeached presidents. Now, with Keiko Fujimori in office as president, the boot is on the other foot. However, although opposition parties have more seats in the Chamber, those in the Senate are divided roughly equally between FP and its right-wing allies (in Renovación Popular) and those of the leftward-leaning opposition parties.