In an open letter to international aid agencies and governments, AIDESEP, the national Amazonian indigenous organisation, asks them to suspend climate funding to government agencies which, in an act of “bad faith”, are blocking the approval of reserves for indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. The call on foreign donors to suspend climate funding to state bodies follows the latter’s failure to approve an EPR recognition study for the Atacuari Indigenous Reserve.
Peru is the Amazonian country with the largest number of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. These are peoples who, largely as a result of persecution and massacres during the rubber boom at the beginning of the last century, retreated into remote regions of the rainforest where they have maintained their traditional lifestyles, cultures and economic activities while maintaining little or no contact with the outside world.
In recent decades, with the internationalisation of the global economy and the extension of extractive economies into the most remote regions of the world, these peoples have come under increasing threats due to the destructive impacts of external economic actors on their natural resources and livelihoods, cultures and, above all, their very existence due to their vulnerability to diseases to which they have little or no immunity.
To protect these vulnerable communities, AIDESEP has promoted the creation of indigenous reserves covering their territories so as to guarantee them protection and enable them to establish contacts with others only when they so choose to do so.
In 1978, Decree Law 22175 established the regulatory framework for recognising indigenous communities in the Amazon, but it was not designed for the situation of indigenous in voluntary isolation. In 2006, Law 28736 was passed to establish a regulatory framework within which to protect their rights, including their right to refuse contact with the rest of Peruvian society.
Under this legislation a multisectoral commission was established to oversee the process for creating and approving indigenous reserves. To establish a reserve a Previous Recognition Study (EPR for its initials in Spanish) must be carried out based on anthropological evidence and rigorous scientific proof to determine the existence of peoples in voluntary isolation. Once the EPR was approved, an Additional Categorisation Study (EAC) must be prepared and approved before a reserve can finally be created.
Implementing this process has proven to be excruciatingly slow. The multisectoral commission has faced of opposition and delays from government agencies. For example, after 20 years of deliberation, including eight years of exhaustive field work, the commission failed to approve the proposal for the Yavari Mirim Indigenous Reserve in September 2025. Had it been approved, this reserve would have protected more than 1.16 million hectares of rainforest and, with it, the fundamental rights of five indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation.
With this experience in mind and with the approval of the EPR for the proposed Atacuari Indigenous Reserve by the Multisectoral Commission scheduled for 7 October, AIDESEP published its open letter describing the constant manoeuvres by agencies to prevent the approval of indigenous reserves. It has called on the Norwegian, German and United Kingdom governments, the German Development Bank and the World Bank – signatories of the Joint Declaration of Intent (DCI) within the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) which had financed the EPR – to suspend climate funding to the Ministry of Agriculture (MINAGRI), the Forestry Service (SERFOR), the Loreto Regional Government and the Ministry for the Environment (MINAM) if the EPR for the Atacuari Indigenous Reserve was not approved.
As AIDESEP had feared, in the meeting of the Multisectoral Commission to consider the Atacuari EPR, despite all the evidence that has been collected, representatives of MINAM, the Ministry of Energy and Mines, MINAGRI, the Ministries of the Interior and Defence, the Loreto government and the Mariscal Ramon Castilla and Putumayo provincial municipalities voted against approving the EPR. Although the Peruvian Amazonian Nationalities Confederation (CONAP), the Ministries of Culture, Health and Education, and San Marcos (UNMSM) and Catholic (PUCP) Universities voted in favour, the EPR was rejected by eight votes to seven.
The failure to approve the EPR not only signifies the closure of a technical procedure but also closing an institutional route designed to recognise and protect the rights of peoples whose existence has been established through specialised evidence.
AIDESEP points to the contradiction of the institutions voting against the approval receiving millions of dollars in climate finance from European governments while frustrating the protection of the territories of peoples in voluntary isolation, undermining conservation of the biodiversity and ecosystems of their habitat.
It demands that the state guarantee that the decisions affecting indigenous peoples in isolation are adopted based on scientific evidence, technical criteria and in conformity with national and international obligations to protect their rights. It is also demanding transparency that the technical arguments supporting the decision be made public.
While these procedures follow their course the territories under consideration continue to be exposed to multiple pressures, including overlapping rights and the expansion of illegal activities, placing at risk the lives and health of those in voluntary isolation.
Recent Comments