On 11 April, ten years and two trials later, following the assassination of four Asheninka indigenous leaders of the Alto Tamaya-Saweto community, two of those charged have been condemned. At the moment of the assassinations, Edwin Chota, Jorge Ríos, Leoncio Quintisima and Francisco Pinedo were heading to a meeting with fellow indigenous in Brazil to coordinate efforts to defend their territories against illegal logging.

The trial began in June 2022 and, at the end of February 2023, the perpetrators were sentenced to 28 years in gaol and to 200,000 soles payable as civil compensation. However, in August the decision was annulled on a technicality, and a new trial began in November concluding in March 2024, with the verdict finally announced last month.

Indigenous leaders and human rights defenders celebrated the decision as the first case where assassins of a human rights defender have been convicted, setting a precedent for future cases and ending the impunity previously enjoyed. However, of the five persons charged, only two were convicted. The other three were released on bail pending further investigation. The bail conditions require that they remain in their residences and avoid contact with the victims’ families.

Ruth Luque, the president of the Indigenous Peoples Commission in Congress, has warned that the bail conditions would allow the three charged to flee or to threaten witnesses and/or family members. The latter have expressed their fears because one of the accused lives in the same community of Saweto (which has only 35 families) and his family has been threatening the widows of the victims.

Luque is demanding that the Interior Ministry and Judiciary take measures to protect them using the mechanism for protecting human rights defenders. A senior official in the EU Embassy, Jerome Poussielgue, has also asked that the widows and witnesses be offered proper protection.

In addition to the charges pending against three of the accused, those already condemned have the right to appeal to the Supreme Court.