Peru this week broke diplomatic relations with Mexico, following the Mexican decision to offer diplomatic asylum to Peru’s former prime minister, Betssy Chávez. The Mexican ambassador, Karia Ornelas has been ordered to leave the country. The Mexican foreign ministry responded saying that it “lamented and rejected” Peru’s decision, claiming that it had acted in accordance with international norms on asylum, specifically the Caracas declaration of 1954. Mexico claims that offering asylum cannot be construed as an “unfriendly act” as alleged by the Peruvian government.

Chávez had previously been released from detention following a ruling by the Constitutional Tribunal. She had been under preventative detention since 2023. She was prime minister at the time that former president Pedro Castillo ordered the closure of Congress in December 2022. Castillo was subsequently impeached and imprisoned. The public prosecutor had requested a prison term of 26 years for Chávez and 34 for Castillo on charges of ‘rebellion’.

Relations between Peru and Mexico have been strained ever since Castillo’s arrest. Following his abortive attempt to close down Congress, he had tried to seek refuge in the Mexican embassy but was arrested before he could reach it. The government of former president Andrés Manuel López Obrador had claimed that Castillo was being held as a political prisoner. The Colombian government also was highly critical of the way in which Castillo had been imprisoned.

In a statement, the Mexican authorities said that Chávez and her lawyers had alleged that she had been the object of “repeated violations of her human rights” while in custody. They said that her appeal for asylum had been granted under Article 11 of the Mexican Constitution “following a detailed and strict” application of established procedures. The foreign ministry also said the Peruvian response was “excessive and disproportionate”.

For his part, Peru’s current foreign minister, Hugo De Zela, told a press conference that Mexico “on repeated occasions” had sought to interfere in Peru’s domestic politics with an “incoherent narrative” about what happened in December 2022.  He claimed that Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum had recently made “inacceptable and false” claims to the effect that Castillo was a political prisoner.

At the time of going to press, it was still unclear whether Chávez would be given safe conduct to travel to Mexico. A decision on the matter was pending, but Peru now wants member countries of the Organization of American States to amend the Caracas Convention.

In a parallel move, the Peruvian foreign ministry this week ‘invited’ the Cuban ambassador, Carlos Zamora, to leave the country. Members of Congress have long criticised Zamora for supposed involvement in promoting anti-government demonstrations.