‘Putting Peru Back Together’ was the wildly optimistic and inaccurate title of an event held at the Wilson Center in Washington on 21 February. The content however was better than the title. Two commentators, both past presidents, were in conversation over the reasons for Peru’s difficulties: Ivan Duque, the former conservative president of Colombia (2018-22), and Francisco Sagasti, former interim president of Peru (2020-21). The chair was Juan Jose Neyra. Beatriz Garcia introduced the session.

Both speakers emphasised the historical legacies that cramp Peru, making for strong centralisation on Lima and resulting in weak regional structures of political representation and government. Sagasti described the document that he and some colleagues have developed since his time in office, ‘Agenda Peru’. This refers to what he called the ‘diversity of diversities’ that is Peru, a deep diversity that is a richness that policy has failed to take proper advantage of. He also gave an eloquent analysis of Peru’s instability but insisted that it has been an achievement of the country to handle extremes of right and left within the constraints imposed by the constitution.

Duque proffered a similar analysis, focusing on institutional weakness, then passing to what Peru could learn from Colombia. He referred to Colombia’s relative success in the introduction of the popularly elected governors and mayors in the 1980s and how this empowered regional and local government. In his view, Colombia had benefited from unusually strong regional infrastructure, both physical and in terms of human resources. He argued that Peruvian parties should get together to build consensus, not just around elections but a consensus that can provide for government after an election, a “national unity cabinet”. He said that a total reform of the constitution was not needed but spelt out some detailed reforms he saw as important.

Sagasti responded emphasising the historical differences between the two countries. The strong spread of regional and local government in recent years in Colombia’s case led to relatively effective local government, not so in Peru.