On the night of 9 October, the congressional long knives came out for Dina Boluarte, forcing her out of the presidency of Peru. Following her near-unanimous impeachment, she joins the list of ex-presidents, most of whom are in jail. Her replacement, José Jeri, since last July the president of Congress, was sworn as caretaker successor pending the outcome of next April’s general elections. He has promised a crackdown on organised crime, the issue on which Boluarte was found wanting.

Jeri is a lawyer and member of Congress for Somos Perú, the grouping originally founded by former Lima Mayor Alberto Andrade in 1995. He is a little known political entity who was investigated by the public prosecutor for rape (violación sexual) and illicit enrichment. The rape charges against him were formally dropped last August. However, since being sworn in a number of social media messages have emerged in which he voiced misogynist views.

His first challenge will be to take steps to avoid a national strike by transport workers on 15 October. Students and Generation-Z protestors are likely to support such a march. The precedent of Manuel Merino, the president appointed by Congress in 2020 to replace Martín Vizcarra as president and who lasted only a week in office, may loom large over Jeri.

The impeachment of Boluarte was carried by 113 votes (with one abstention and one against), well above the 87 required to impeach a president. Almost all parties in Congress, with the sole exception of Honor y Democracia, rallied around the move, initiated by Renovación Popular (RP), most of which had been those who had kept Boluarte in office.

The trigger for the move appears to have been an attack at a concert at the Chorrillos military base the night before in Lima in which five people were wounded. But it is unclear whether her ouster formed part of a more pre-meditated action; the volte-face on the part of numerous right-wing parties, including Keiko Fujimori’s Fuerza Popular, would appear to have required prior planning and consultations.

But what is clear is that, for these, Boluarte had outlived her usefulness as head of state at a time when, for many, they needed to distance themselves from a president whose popularity could statistically fall no further.

Those who Jeri intends to appoint as cabinet ministers will provide clues as to where policy goes from here. His initial remarks suggested that he would seek to take more drastic steps than Boluarte to crack down on the criminal mafias whose activities have generated a deep climate of insecurity within Peruvian society. What these measures will consist of, and whether they stand a better chance than Boluarte’s to resolve the problem, will become clearer over the coming days and weeks.

Boluarte’s removal from office comes after weeks of protest by transport workers and others at her government’s inefficacy in resolving the problem of delinquency. Transport workers repeatedly took to the streets over the last year in protest at their exposure to extortion by criminal gangs, Past weekends have also seen recurrent marches by Gen-Z protestors in Lima and other cities with bitter clashes with the police.

If it is to do any better, the new government will need to employ more imaginative policies than simply declaring ‘states of emergency’ giving wide powers to the police and the army. For many, the forces of order are more part of the problem than the solution. An emergency crackdown may involve authoritarian postures that are hardly compatible with the pursuit of democratic elections. The ‘Bukele solution’, as practiced in El Salvador, shows the two objectives to be incompatible.

In a message to the nation shortly after her removal from office, Boluarte claimed to have sought to have ruled Peru democratically and in the public interest. “At all times I invoked unity, to work together, to struggle for our country; in this I did not think of myself but of the more than 34 million Peruvians who deserve growth with democratic stability and with a government that worked without corruption as we have been doing”, she said in her parting speech. Since leaving office, she has denied rumours that she intended to skip Peru and seek refuge in another country.

Boluarte’s popularity ratings were rarely above 3% over the past two years. Her government was criticised both at home and abroad for its scant regard for democratic norms and human rights. Readers of this newsletter will attest to the legacy of the killings in southern Peru at the end of 2022, to the legislation to absolve from justice those guilty of crimes against humanity, to her receipt of gifts in return for political favours, to her use of public funds for personal political ends, to the attempt to protect her associates from justice, and to the efforts to close down investigations into such acts.

As Peru’s eighth president in less than a decade takes office, the legacy left by Boluarte could hardly be worse.