In a serious reverse for the judiciary, and especially the public prosecution service, a court has ruled the annulment of the case against Keiko Fujimori and 32 other members of Fuerza Popular (FP) for their role in the so-called ‘cocktails case’. The case against them will have to be submitted to a fresh trial. The ruling is a victory for Keiko and her legal team, providing a significant breathing space for Fujimori and her colleagues.
As readers will recall, Fujimori was at the centre of a scandal by which election campaign payments to FP by Odebrecht, the Brazilian construction company, were disguised to appear as contributions by party supporters in fund raising events. Owing to alleged procedural mistakes, the prosecution will need to re-present the case against Fujimori, further delaying a decision on events that took place nearly ten years ago.
The Constitutional Tribunal (TC) had previously ruled that the case against José Chlimper, one of Fujimori’s closest confidants in FP, was vitiated due to these procedural shortcomings. The court ruling unanimously upheld these findings. However, the same court went on to rule – by a majority of two to one – that by the same token the cases against all 33 were to be annulled.
The discordant vote came from Judge Nayko Coronado. He argued that the ruling represented a “violation of the principle of legality”. He argued that while the case against Chlimper was vitiated, this should not extend automatically to the other 32 accused. He also argued that there was no legal basis for annulling a trial that had yet to be concluded.
Immediately, the prosecutor on the case, José Domingo Pérez, lodged an appeal against the decision. It remains to be seen whether this is declared admissible. It may well be the case that the charges against Fujimori and her co-defendants end up being shelved.
The ruling comes as a serious blow both to Pérez and to Judge Víctor Zúñiga who had previously validated the case. It is also a severe blow to the reputation of the judiciary and the whole campaign to confront corruption and organised crime in Peru. The case against the 33 had already suffered from repeated procedural failings.
In a parallel development, the case against former president Ollanta Humala, his wife Nadine Heredia and their collaborator Wilfredo Pedraza, is entering a crucial stage, over how their presidential campaigns were funded in 2006 and 2011. They too stand accused of receiving undeclared donations, in their case from Venezuela. The same three judges are set to rule on the case. The prosecutor is Germán Juárez Atoche.
Whatever the verdict, this will not necessarily be the end of the matter since, if convicted, the defendants are likely to appeal to a higher court. Humala denies receiving illicit funding from the former Venezuelan president, Hugo Chávez.
Recent Comments