Two recent reports document the complex interrelations between climate change, drought, and deforestation in the Amazon. The first report, issued by World Weather Attribution (WWA), a network of scientists from five European research institutes, presents evidence indicating that the current drought in the Amazon is not due exclusively to the El Niño phenomenon but also – and largely – to climate change.
The second report, issued by the Monitoring of the Andean Amazon Project (MAAP), an initiative of Amazon Conservation and Conservación Amazónica (ACCA), has published some 200 reports since 2015 documenting deforestation in the Amazon, especially the southwestern Amazon, covering Peru and Ecuador. Its most recent report presents an overview of deforestation trends in the Amazon basin.
The WWA report observes that since mid-2023 the Amazon basin has suffered an exceptional drought driven by low rainfall and consistently high temperatures. River levels are reported to be at their lowest levels in 120 years, threatening the livelihoods of an estimated 30 million people.
The WWA seeks to investigate the extent to which extreme weather is attributable to climate change and not solely to cyclical phenomena, such as El Niño. In the case of the Amazon, it has done this by distinguishing between the meteorological drought (attributable to El Niño) and the agricultural drought (attributable to climate change).
The report finds that smallholder farmers, indigenous, rural and river communities were among the most vulnerable due to high poverty rates and their dependency on agricultural food production, the availability of fresh water, and the import of goods via rivers.
This exposure to drought impacts was compounded by historical land, water, and energy management practices, including deforestation, destruction of vegetation, fires, biomass burning, corporate farming, and cattle ranching.
WWA also found that while there is a strong drying trend in the meteorological drought, the trend in agricultural drought is even stronger, meaning such an agricultural drought would have been extremely rare in a cooler climate.
El Niño reduced precipitation in the region by about the same amount as climate change; however, the strong drying trend was almost entirely due to increased global temperatures. Thus, the severity of the drought has largely been driven by climate change. What is now classified as an exceptional drought (D4), would have only been a ‘severe drought’ (D2) without the effects of climate change, caused by burning fossil fuels and deforestation.
WWA concludes by saying that despite “low confidence” in IPCC projections for drought in the region, increasing water stress driven by human-induced climate change continues to be a major threat for the population and requires urgent efforts for more effective water management strategies, an interdisciplinary humanitarian response, and for regional cooperation that includes farmers and other stakeholders in the planning.
MAAP’s 200th report warns that the Amazon is approaching two critical points brought on by deforestation. The first is the feared conversion of the rainforest into dry zones or savannahs due to the reduction in rain cycles. The second and more recent critical point is the conversion of the Amazon from a carbon sink that cushions global climate change, into a source of carbon emissions.
It points out that almost half the Amazon is designated protected areas and that indigenous territories have deforestation rates much lower than adjacent areas. Furthermore, recent data from the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) show that the Amazon has more abundant carbon reserves than previously thought.
Finally, it shows that, between 2022 and 2023, there was an important reduction in the loss of primary forest in the Amazon, especially in Brazil and Colombia, indicating that political will and government policies can make a difference.
In this context, Peru is the third largest contributor to deforestation after Brazil and Bolivia. Deforestation has been especially fast in Peru’s central Amazon region due to the destructive activities of the Mennonite colonies. MAAP’s real time reports show that Mennonite destruction increased from zero in 2016 to 3,400 hectares in 2021, 4,800 hectares in 2022 and 7,032 hectares in 2023.
In the southern Amazon area, gold mining continues to be one of the principal causes of deforestation, mainly in indigenous communities, in the buffer zones of protected areas and in the officially designated ‘mining corridor’. Between 2021 and 2023 gold mining deforested almost 24,000 hectares.
Recent Comments