On 23 June, via Oficio No. 383-2021-PR, President Francisco Sagasti returned a proposed law to Congress with observations (No. 6486/2020-CR) intended to promote the construction of a highway from Pucallpa to Cruzeiro do Sul in Brazil that was unviable due to the social and environmental impacts involved. As this newsletter has informed, the draft law had previously been criticised by the Ministry of the Environment and the Ombudsman’s Office (Defensoría del Pueblo), as well as by indigenous and civil society organisations.

There was no consultation prior to the law being drafted with the indigenous peoples who would be affected, despite the fact that part of the proposed highway would cross titled indigenous communities, directly affecting the territory of Shipibo and Asháninka peoples and putting at risk the lives and health of peoples protecting the Isconahua Indigenous Reserve.

For its part, the Ministry of the Environment pointed out that the project did not take into account any analysis of the multiple factors that affect Amazonian ecosystems. Furthermore, declarations of national interest and public need, such as those contained in the proposed law, are not compatible with the processes of project evaluation contained in the National System of Multi-year Programming and Investment Management.

A previous proposal presented in 2011 by the ProVias Nacional programme was rejected by the Ministry of Transport because it had not been approved by the Brazilian government and contained no cost-benefit analysis or adequate justification. The proposed highway would cross the Serra do Divisor National Park in Brazil which was declared to be a Natural Heritage for Humanity by UNESCO in 2017.

Once again, we see a proposal being put forward that has not been consulted with the affected population, the relevant ministries and government agencies, or even the Congress’s own Indigenous Peoples and Environment Commission. It was not supported by the relevant technical studies and arguments and responded rather to pressures from special vested interests in Congress.

Its approval by the full Congress came probably with the expectation that it would be returned by the executive with observations. Most likely it will be simply ignored by the next Congress inaugurated later this month.