On 16 August, President Dina Boluarte, supported by her cabinet, proposed a Law on Territorial Planning and creation of a national territorial planning system. Under this, territorial planning and the proposed National Territorial Planning System (SINADOT in Spanish) would sit under the prime minister’s office (PCM), leading the coordination with other interested ministries and agencies.
The aim of the proposal is to provide leadership in land and resource management, coordinating the various state organisations currently responsible for permits and land/resource oversight.
The proposals encompass a range of issues in connection with land and resource management. Primary amongst these are an integrated approach to government land management and the use of land according to its productivity (framed as competition between different uses). The approach seeks to “promote an orderly occupation of the territory and proper use of natural resources…”. Yet it also recognises issues such as human rights, disaster management, adaptation to climate change and decentralisation.
These changes come on the back of other proposals, about which we have written previously, to place the National Environmental Certification Service for Sustainable Investments (Senace) under the PCM, whilst merging other environmental oversight and management bodies together.
These two sets of proposals would involve a significant increase in power for the PCM over the management of the ministries and agencies concerned with the management and oversight of land management and natural resource use.
CooperAcción, an NGO long critical of extractivism, assesses that these proposals, combined with others recently proposed, will come at the expense of environmental protection and pose a risk to communities, including indigenous groups living in isolation, whilst increasing the benefits for big business and the broader extractive sector. In particular Cooperacción notes that:
“Experience shows that, if you want any institution or policy not to work, you house it in the PCM. This has happened with the Vice Ministry of Territorial Governance, with the National Centre for Strategic Planning (CEPLAN) and several other organizations. The PCM is an eminently political body, also characterised by strong instability: if in Peru, in the span of six years we have had six presidents of the republic, in that same period sixteen people have held the position of presidency of the Council of Ministers, in some cases with stays of just a few days.”
There is a case to be made for seeing these systems better coordinated and run more smoothly. There can be difficulties coordinating between different organisation and there are significant delays to decisions over applications for mining and other projects. However, the move to consolidate the different institutions under the PCM, combining control over territory/resource management and environmental approvals under the same office (even if via two different laws) will be seen as a power grab, potentially putting at risk environmental and rights protection for the public whilst favouring big business. It places at further risk the already poor public trust in government and the institutions of state.
Recent Comments