Prime Minister Alberto Otárola has given his backing to a controversial proposal by the National Society of Mining, Petroleum and Energy (SNMPE) to incorporate multiple environmentally-focused government agencies of the Ministry of the Environment (MinAm) into the National Environmental Certification Service for Sustainable Investments (Senace). Under these proposals, this new Senace would no longer answer to the environment minister but would be overseen by the prime minister’s office (PCM).
The proposal envisages Senace absorbing the National Service of National Protected Areas for the State (Sernamp), the National Service for Forests and Wildlife (Serfor) and the National Water Authority (ANA).
SNMPE argues that the current process for the environmental approval of investment projects is disjointed, too slow, and fails to provide confidence to investors. The president of SNMPE, Víctor Gobitz, says that it is not aiming to reduce the weight given to environmental oversight but to concentrate the guidelines and professionals in a single governing body that streamlines project approval.
According to Gobitz, “the idea is that Senace reports to the PCM because it should respond to a vision of the country and have the capacity to be flexible with its budget. If you put it under a ministry, the other ministries are equal. In comparison, if it is under the PCM, you are achieving something more.”
However, experts have significant concerns. They argue that these state agencies do not solely exist to consider extractive projects; they consider environmental impact assessments as part of a larger portfolio of concerns under their environmental remit. Taking environmental assessments away from the larger view of environmental policy management would weaken environmental protections.
The former vice-minister for the environment, José De Echave, notes that some mining representatives have consistently pushed against having state institutions to protect the environment. He argues that “if we want to talk of sustainability, the path needs to be exactly the opposite. Remember that Senace was created in 2012 with the aim of creating a technical specialist body responsible for the independent evaluation of Environmental Impact Studies (EIAs). The EIA represents the principal technical instrument which permits the inclusion of the environment in decisions over projects using natural resources or infrastructure … for this reason it is fundamental to have an independent institution … with the funding it requires.”
The former environment minister, Gabriel Quijandría, said that bringing together the institutions was “not understanding anything”, noting that for Sernamp “the consideration of Environmental Impact Studies (EIAs) is a secondary theme in its mandate”, and that the proposals looked to “turn back the clock ten years to have direct control over the approval of EIAs … putting it under the PCM makes the process political.”
Facilitating extractive projects involves increasing public confidence in protecting their environmental and social impacts. Placing the combined responsibilities of multiple agencies under Senace and the PCM threatens further to politicise an already conflict-ridden extractives sector. If enacted, this proposal is likely further to undermine public confidence among communities as to the neutrality of government decisions on the approval of mining projects, their economic and social impacts, and their impacts on health and rural livelihoods.
Recent Comments