A recent report prepared for the NGO HIVOS by the environmental lawyer Carlos Soria analyses the incipient state of development of legal protections for environmental and human rights defenders in the Peruvian Amazon. It presents recommendations for their strengthening.
The report observes that the assassinations, aggressions and threats against human rights defenders, indigenous territories and the environment are ever more frequent in the Amazon and exceed the capacity of the Peruvian state to control them.
The principal risk that defenders face is living in border areas where private actors are gradually surrounding them and appropriating public and communal properties for their private use. In response, the state has shown itself unable to apply the law or to meet its obligations with citizens.
One of the report’s main conclusions is that the institutional legal framework for the protection of defenders has only recently been developed and is still incipient. This normative framework needs to be further developed and adapted to the complexity of the socioeconomic situation on the ground with criminal forces in play. It needs to be able and to mobilise the necessary resources in order to neutralise the actions of illegal actors.
In an interview, Soria recommends that successful experiences of law enforcement need to be disseminated so that those responsible for enforcing the law understand how to proceed correctly. He offers as examples the prosecution of the Saweto assassins and the apprehension of those charged with the assassination of the indigenous leader Inuma Quinto. He suggests that a training manual based on these experiences be prepared.
Soria also observes that not all assassinations are of those defending their territory and natural resources; sometimes they are hate crimes. These too need to be combatted, he says, adding that concepts of tolerance, coexistence and diversity have to be promoted. Technical and legal support also needs to be provided to indigenous lawyers working to protect those indigenous defenders who are under threat.
Up until now, the legal measures to protect defenders have been “basically declarative” and need to be further developed, Soria argues, although he adds that there have been some significant advances in the behaviour of the police.
Recent Comments