The legislative term ended on 15 July without sufficient votes to approve – for now – a bill to reform the constitution along the lines demanded by Peru’s far right parties. The vote in Congress was passed on 15 July by 71 to 45 (with six abstentions), not enough to approve a constitutional amendment. Constitutional reforms require a two-thirds majority in two successive legislatures or ratification in a referendum.
The bill promised to tilt the balance of power away from the executive towards the legislature. It had been previously approved by a majority in the Constitution Commission of the Congress, presided over by the arch-Fujimorista Patricia Juárez. It posited a number of changes to the constitution. Chief among them was the restoration of a two-chamber Congress with the re-introduction of the Senate and the ending of the prohibition against immediate re-election of members of Congress. Both of these reforms had been voted down in a referendum in December 2019 during the government of Martín Vizcarra.
The package also included other key reforms such as the direct election by Congress of the Comptroller of the Republic, the ability of Congress to pass constitutional accusations against the electoral authorities, and – of particular importance – a restriction on the ability of a sitting president to dissolve Congress. Under the 1993 constitution, a president may dissolve Congress in the event of two successive votes in Congress of no-confidence in the cabinet during a five-year presidential period.
The end of the legislature brings to an end the controversial congressional presidency of María del Carmen Alva, with a new president due to be selected in the coming days. Alva, from Acción Popular, emerged as a key ally of the far-right parties in Congress – Fuerza Popular, Avanza País and Renovación Popular. She adopted a highly confrontational position with respect to President Pedro Castillo, at one point even suggesting that the armed forces were ready to remove him. In recent weeks, she was accused of using racist language by saying that the Congress was working for all Peruvians “poor and rich, whites and Indians” (“pobres y ricos, blancos e indios”).
Among one of the more eyebrow-raising decisions taken last week in the legislature was that to disinvite the Organization of American States from holding its next general assembly in Lima on account of the OAS insistence about providing unisex toilet facilities. According to the Fujimorista president of the Commission on Foreign Relations “the OAS seeks to introduce changes to domestic Peruvian law, invoking gender ideology”. In the end and just before the legislative term ended, Congress backed down on this. It had faced a barrage of criticism.
Throughout the past year, parties of the right in Congress have doggedly opposed one of Castillo’s key electoral promises to reform the 1993 constitution by an elected constituent assembly. For those on the left, the 1993 constitution provided the legal framework for the transformative neoliberal reforms of the Fujimori era. Business groups, in particular, see this as leading to a more interventionist constitution that would run counter to their interests.
The constitutional reforms of the right are likely to resurface in the next legislature. Alternatively, they could be put to a referendum.
Recent Comments