With the Castillo administration nearing its first anniversary in office amid growing signs of dissatisfaction on all sides, La República published an interview that it conducted with Steve Levitzky a leading academic at Harvard University. Levitzky is a seasoned observer of Peruvian politics as well as a recognised authority on the strengths and weaknesses of Latin American democracy.
His views in reference to President Pedro Castillo are, to borrow from Hilaire Belloc, ‘hold on to nurse for fear of something worse’. His assessment of Peru’s president is hardly flattering, casting him as inept and unable to build a coalition to provide Peru with a reasonable level of governance. However, he shows scepticism as to whether bringing forward general elections – one oft-repeated way out of the political impasse – would resolve anything. “I almost guarantee”, he says, “it would produce more of the same”. It would end in “a fragmented Congress full of novices and outsiders that, basically, seek to earn money”.
Although a new presidential election might lead to a less inept president, he thinks it could lead to “a more corrupt and dangerous outsider”. Castillo, he thinks, lacks the talent to become either a powerful autocrat or a major criminal. A successor, he thinks, might be more charismatic and pose a greater danger to Peru’s beleaguered democracy.
The problem, he thinks, lies not so much in the individual but to the weakness of the state and the lack of political parties. These two factors intertwine to weaken democratic governance.
Asked what someone like him who specialises in the conditions in which democracy collapses thinks about the threat to democracy in Peru, he sees a partial answer in the collapse of the party system. This he attributes to the legacy of Alberto Fujimori in the 1990s creating a system in which “many are there [in Congress] just to make money”. And once a party system is broken, it is “very difficult” to put it back together again.
Levitzky seems to think the best option is for political actors “to take a step back” and to avert a dangerous showdown between the executive power and the legislature. He quotes Alberto Vergara, a Peruvian political analyst, in saying that what is needed is a minimal agreement between the two: for Congress to pull back from its threat of impeaching the president, and the president to avoid seeking to use his powers to close down Congress. Both these rights are vested in the 1993 constitution.
He thus thinks that the best solution is to let Castillo serve out his term until 2026. “You need to think of a government which ends in 2026, not before, and you need to work with this in mind”. The results of the 2021 election should be respected and that “an inept Castillo was better than an authoritarian [Keiko] Fujimori”. Had Castillo trusted in Mirtha Vásquez who briefly came in as prime minister late last year, the outcome would have been better.
A figure surprisingly absent in this interview is Vladimir Cerrón who, arguably, has been just as defiant in his stance towards Castillo as the politicians of the far right.
Recent Comments