On 28 July, a year after officially taking office, President Pedro Castillo will give his annual speech to Congress outlining what he plans to do over the next twelve months. However, there are growing doubts as to whether he will last that long. As we have made clear in any number of newsletters over the last few months, he faces pressures from all sides to quit. Much will depend on whether he will try to soldier on or on how his exit happens and when.
Castillo’s speech to Congress will provide clues, and we will report on this next week. He may also decide that it is an appropriate moment for a further reshuffle of his cabinet with a view to rebuilding support. His own popularity has suffered a severe decline in recent months. However, choosing a more independent cabinet would run the risk of him losing the little political authority that he currently enjoys. Indeed, it may now be too late for such an option.
There has been growing speculation that he may eventually accept the need for fresh elections. Moves are afoot to gather signatures to bring forward the date and elect a new president and a new Congress. Francisco Sagasti, who was the interim president following the impeachment of Martín Vizcarra in November 2020, has associated himself with moves to this end.
However, commentators have pointed out that without a major change in the rules of the game, fresh elections will not necessarily bring a better result, either in the choice of a new president or in the selection of new members of Congress. As Steven Levitzky suggested two weeks ago, the problem is more structural and lies in the inoperancy of a democratic party system in Peru.
Meanwhile, as it reassembles for a new parliamentary term, Congress is unlikely to desist from its attempts to try and force Castillo out by constitutional means. In spite of the fragmentation of the party which backed Castillo’s presidential bid in 2021, these smaller groups will almost certainly continue to unite in opposition to attempts by the far-right parties to impeach the president.
To impeach Castillo would require the support of two-thirds of Congress, an 87-vote majority. Unless parts of what was Perú Libre decide to throw in their lot with the opposition, such a majority is hard to achieve. Procedures for impeachment are set out in Article 113 of the constitution. Two attempts to impeach Castillo over the last year have failed to win sufficient support.
According to David Sulmont, head of political science at the Catholic University, “there is no majority in parliament disposed to impeach him or construct a transitional outcome because [having] a weak government is functional to the interests of certain groups”. He goes on “there is an equilibrium there and this could be maintained for some time yet”. One way out, he notes, would be to appoint a more independent prime minister but Castillo lacks the strength to do so. “He nominated Mirtha Vásquez, who had more weight and independence, but allowed her to fall by privileging [the interests] of his closer interest group”, Sulmont is quoted as saying.
The other route to achieving Castillo’s removal is by invoking Articles 99 and 100 under which the Permanent Commission in Congress can launch a constitutional accusation against the president with Congress empowered (in a vote without the members of the Permanent Commission) to suspend the incumbent, force resignation and/or the deprivation of his or her political rights for up to ten years. Moves are afoot in this direction, based on allegations of corruption that are being investigated by the public prosecutor.
However, this appears to contradict what is laid out in Article 117 which stipulates that a president can only be accused during his or her term of office on very specific grounds which include such charges as treason, interference in elections, or closing down Congress unconstitutionally. Charges over corruption are not mentioned as grounds.
The Constitutional Tribunal has the last word when it comes to interpreting the constitution, and under its new membership is likely to be more accommodating towards the opposition than to the president.
Recent Comments