In what is regarded as a highly polemical decision, the Constitutional Tribunal (TC), on the casting vote of its president, ruled that former president Alberto Fujimori should be freed from jail forthwith. Fujimori, who is now 83, was condemned in 2009 to 25 years of imprisonment for his role in ordering the Barrios Altos and La Cantuta killings in 1991 and 1992 respectively. The ruling clashes with one proffered by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) which may have the last word on the matter.
The ruling reverses a decision of the Supreme Court in 2018 that challenged the pardon extended by then president Pedro Pablo Kuczynski to Fujimori at Christmas 2017 as part of a deal with Fujimori’s son, Kenji, and his fellow legislators to avert Kuczynski’s possible impeachment. The Supreme Court ruled that the pardon vitiated a ruling of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. The Supreme Court also questioned the legality of the procedures followed to pardon Fujimori.
Kuczynski, who narrowly beat Keiko Fujimori in the 2016 presidential elections, was consistently the target of attacks by the main party in Congress, the pro-Fujimori Fuerza Popular (FP) led by Fujimori’s daughter. Shortly after, in March 2018, Kuczynski resigned the presidency under the threat of imminent impeachment.
The TC’s decision to reverse the Supreme Court’s decision is highly contentious. It was passed only on the casting vote of its president, Luis Ferrero, a noted conservative. The vote pitted three conservative judges – Ferrero, Ernesto Blume and José Luis Sardón – against three more progressive ones – Marianella Ledesma, Eloy Espinosa-Saldaña and Manuel Miranda. When the judgement is tied like this, the president may vote twice.
Until recently, Ledesma was the president of the TC, and under her aegis, the Court tended to make less conservative decisions. Normally, the TC should have seven members, thus avoiding the need for a casting vote. Its seventh member died last year. Six of the members of the TC should have retired some years ago, but they remain in post so long as the Congress fails to elect replacements. An election last year had to be scrapped.
Ferrero has a record of voting in favour of the Fujimori cause. He voted for the freeing of Keiko Fujimori from detention and against former president Martín Vizcarra’s controversial dissolution of Congress in 2019. He appears to have held a meeting with Keiko Fujimori in 2017, just before he became a member of the TC.
The freeing of Alberto Fujimori represents a major political victory for FP and the pro-Fujimori right. Although the 83-year-old former president is ailing and represents no political threat himself, FP has long seen his release as one of its key political objectives. FP seeks to uphold the legacy of Fujimori’s ten-year period in office (1990-2000) during which Peru underwent a neoliberal ‘revolution’. The decision comes days before FP and its allies in Congress hope to impeach President Pedro Castillo.
To his opponents, Fujimori’s rule was despotic, corrupt and saw the widespread violation of basic human rights. The decision to free Fujimori has been criticised by Castillo and more left-wing members of Congress and those in the human rights community. Tamara Taraciuk, acting director of Human Rights Watch expressed her “enormous concern” at the decision. “Fujimori was condemned for very serious violations of human rights” she says, “the pardon he was offered in 2017 was a false one without any justification. Reviving it is a mockery to victims”.
The decision to take up Fujimori’s habeas corpus plea was adopted by Blume on 16 March. The speed at which the TC ruled on the matter took public opinion largely by surprise. Under Ferrero’s presidency, the TC has made a number of landmark conservative decisions, such as the refusal to regard free, prior and informed consent for indigenous peoples as a constitutionally endorsed principle.
The only way to challenge the decision of the TC is through a renewed appeal to the IACHR. According to César Landa, the foreign minister and himself a former member and president of the TC, “the recent decision of the Constitutional Tribunal on the Fujimori case is invalid since it goes against the decisions of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights in the Barrios Altos and La Cantuta cases”. The IACHR has ruled that ‘crimes against humanity’, such as the killings at Barrios Altos and La Cantuta, cannot be the subject of official pardons.
For its part the Peru Europe Platform (PEP), of which the PSG is a member, has issued a statement in which it says it ”firmly rejects the decision” of the TC which, it says “contradicts what was established by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights in its verdict of May 2018 in which it set out that the extension of a pardon in cases of grave violations of human rights goes against international law and constitutes a flagrant violation of the rights to memory, truth, justice and the reparation of victims”.
Recent Comments