A law agreed upon by the Council of Ministers on 20 April chemically to castrate men guilty of the rape of minors has been criticised as “populist” and likely to be costly and ineffectual. The executive sent the measure to Congress for its approval the same day.
The idea is that before their release from prison offenders would be injected to prevent future offending. However, it is unclear exactly when this penalty would be applied. According to Peru’s penal code, those found guilty of raping minors already face life imprisonment.
Announcing the new law, President Pedro Castillo said he hoped that parliament would ratify the measure.
The measure has been objected to on the basis of its likely cost and the fact that any such injection necessitates the consent of the person to which it is applied. Such injections, which would need to be applied monthly, currently cost 300-400 soles according to the Peruvian College of Medicine.
The Ombudsman’s Office (Defensoría del Pueblo) is opposed to the measure which it views as ineffectual in lowering the rate of juvenile rape cases. For its part, the Inter-American Commission of Human Rights has criticised the move saying that chemical castration is “a form of punishment that violates the prohibition on torture and other inhuman and degrading penalties”.
According to Raúl Urquizo from the College of Medicine the draft law is a form of “populism” that does nothing to resolve the problem it seeks to address. What is needed, he says, are more effective preventative measures: Peru lacks psychiatric doctors trained to deal with such matters.
The law responds to protests in northern Peru at a case of a 3-year old who was abducted and sexually abused in the city of Chiclayo.
Former Prime Minister Mirtha Vásquez also criticised the draft law as failing to resolve the problem of sexual violence: this sort of repression simply make matters worse.
Recent Comments