The newly appointed prime minister, Héctor Valer, has been accused of having attempted in 2009 to create an organisation parallel to AIDESEP in the days and weeks that followed the massacre at Bagua. He was an APRA party activist and government official at the time. Valer confirmed in a recent article his views about Amazonian indigenous communities, reiterating those of former President Alan Garcia who famously characterised them as acting as “a dog in the manger” in standing in the way of economic progress.

On 16 June, 2009, in his role as president of the organising commission, Valer announced the proposed creation of the National Peasant and Native Agrarian Confederation (CONAC). At the time, he was the government official responsible for protection, economic development and the environment at the Institute for the Development of the Andean, Amazonian and Afro-Peruvian Peoples (INDEPA). CONAC’s organisers accused AIDESEP’s advisors of being linked to extreme left political parties. They accused the Amazonian leaders of bypassing their legitimate representatives and intermediaries.

Subsequently, on 19 November, Valer, together with Mauricio Mulder, congressman and general secretary of APRA, published a communiqué convening the national meeting to establish CONAC on 5 December at APRA party headquarters. The attempt to create a new organisation to displace AIDESEP proved a failure as only 40 party members attended, the majority residents of Lima, Cuzco, Apurímac and La Libertad. There were no delegates present from Amazonian indigenous communities.

In an interview on Radio Exitosa on 10 January this year, Valer reiterated the views expressed by García in 2009, accusing indigenous communities of being large landholders and allowing small groups to block access to exploitation of the country’s natural resources. He argued that the communities should be dissolved, with their members becoming individual landholders who could then receive loans. He justified these views by claiming that “communal lands lead to communism or parasitic socialism.” He further accused the indigenous peoples of being responsible for oil pipeline spills. He also advocated the elimination of the position of ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo).

For its part, AIDESEP has published an open letter to President Pedro Castillo expressing its indignation at Valer’s appointment. It demands an end to racism and rejects any return to those policies of the García government that had provoked confrontation between indigenous peoples and the police at Bagua.