On 8 August the Lima High Court ruled that the retired admiral and former congressman Carlos Tubino had publicly discriminated against the Shipibo Conibo indigenous people and ordered him to desist from making such declarations in future.

The ruling was in response to a demand presented by Lizardo Cauper, president of the national Amazonian indigenous organisation (AIDESEP) in 2018. Tubino was a member of the pro-Fujimori Fuerza Popular party in Congress and a determined proponent of development in the Amazon. He backed the building of penetration roads regardless of the consequences for the rainforest and the lives and livelihoods of indigenous communities, especially those in voluntary isolation.

On 23 April 2018, Tubino had publicly accused Shipibo Conibo indigenous of having assassinated a Canadian citizen, Sebastian Woodroffe, declaring: “Those savages ought to be apprehended immediately . . . THIS IS ALL THE PRODUCT OF AYAHUASCA!! The Shipibo shamans have made a business of this with foreigners, the bad use of this hallucinogen has produced this tragedy!!”

Subsequent investigations revealed that, in fact, Woodroffe had himself assassinated Olivia Arévalo, a well-known Shipibo Conibo shaman.

The Court determined that, by his declaration, Tubino had besmirched the honour and ethnic and cultural identity of the Shipibo Conibo people.

Although of little material consequence, the court’s ruling sets a precedent aimed at setting limits to public discourse that infringes the rights of others and the right of indigenous peoples to have their honour and identity respected.