Prime Minister Mirtha Vásquez announced on 19 November that four mines in Ayacucho region, including two owned by the London-listed Hochschild, would not be granted further operational extensions due to environmental concerns expressed by local communities, and would be closed shortly. The announcement was made on Twitter along with pictures of the signed agreement with local communities.

The controversy revolves around the extension of time over which extraction can take place at a mine. End of mine plans are submitted when initial approval is requested and are regularly reviewed and altered. Any approval on mines (both initial and continuing) is dependent on meeting the legal obligations placed on miners, including norms about environmental protection.

Vasquez’s announcement saw Hochschild stock value dive 27% on 22 November, and investment ratings drop, reflecting the uncertainty over future production, particularly at the Inmaculada mine, its largest operation. Hochschild’s chief executive, Ignacio Bustamante, responded that the company meets environmental standards and industry best practice.

Hochschild believes that Vásquez’s announcement was not in accordance with Peruvian law and said that the company would seek to engage with the Peruvian government on the matter. If necessary, it says it would use legal avenues to defend its rights.

In a speech in Arequipa on 22 November, President Pedro Castillo distanced himself from Vásquez’s announcement and stated that “unilateral, arbitrary decisions outside of the law will not take place”, and Peru would continue to promote “responsible, modern, and socially and environmentally sustainable mining”.

To negotiate a way forward, the following day cabinet ministers – Vásquez, Eduardo González (Energy and Mines), Rubén Ramírez (Environment), Pedro Francke (Economy and Finance) – met with mining representatives from the four mines under threat of closure, and the National Society of Mining, Petroleum and Energy (SNMPE).

This discussion resulted in a declaration on 24 November that mining extensions will be permitted when they meet regulations, apparently contradicting and reversing the agreement with communities signed by Vásquez less than a week before.

Local communities however insist that the mines should shut and that the agreement they signed with Vásquez is valid. Community leaders noted that they voted for Castillo in the elections and hoped that their views would be listened to. If the government fails to respect the agreement, they say, they will restart demonstrations.

This dispute reflects the challenge the government faces in both representing the interests of the communities around mines whilst attracting mining investment given its importance to the Peruvian economy. Whilst miners claim they meet international environmental and social standards in their operations, local communities often challenge this. These issues are reflected upon in our previous reports on mining conflicts and the reasons for them.