The Peruvian press was reporting no less than seven major active conflicts in the mining sector this last week. The government has been active in intervening to try and secure dialogue.
The last two weeks saw an acceleration of the conflict around the Antamina mine in Ancash, majority owned by Glencore and BHP. The community of Aquia had been blockading the mining corridor there since 30 October, protesting about environmental contamination and the unauthorised use of its territory. The community was demanding the presence of President Pedro Castillo and Prime Minister Mirtha Vásquez. A delegation led by the minister of energy and mines eventually arrived, and on 1 November a dialogue table was established.
At Huarmey on the coast, locals are also protesting at what they see as Antamina’s failure to honour agreements made with the company. Antamina ships out its output through this port.
Other conflicts include Caña Brava (which belongs to the Grupo Romero) in Piura, Oyón in the department of Lima (against the Raura mining company), and at Apumayu in Ayacucho. There remain several extant conflicts over oil in the Amazon.
Given the large vote from mining communities for Castillo in the elections, it is worth a pause to reflect on why we are beginning to see what is looking like an explosion of discontent over extractives projects.
Each conflict has its own history and reflects the complex dynamics interacting between companies and local populations, the taxes paid, jobs gained, community projects undertaken and the actions (or inaction) of local governments. It is important to note that while conflicts about mining are often highlighted in the media, many more communities across Peru are not currently protesting against mining. Protests are neither constant nor uniform.
What we do know is that communities near mines are often living in precarious situations where incomes are low and insecure, and subsistence agriculture forms an important part of livelihood strategies. Such communities cannot afford to wait long for benefits from a new government, however progressive it may appear.
When large-scale mines begin operations, communities can have high hopes about the benefits promised such as jobs and community support projects (e.g. healthcare or improved farming techniques). The prospect of taxes paid to local government (largely through the mining canon) to fund investment/infrastructure projects can also be appealing. And mining companies frequently portray themselves as custodians of the environment.
The reality of life alongside mining can however be very different:
- Jobs and contracts are sometimes not realised. Companies prefer employees who are already qualified and want experienced contractors with the technical expertise. These are usually not locals; instead they usually come from the cities or even from abroad.
- Community projects are most often undertaken only in communities considered as directly impacted by the mines. They omit other nearby communities which may be affected by the mine or the transport of minerals.
- Taxes (largely through the canon minero) can take time to be paid as new mines gradually establish production levels. The income from the canon is shared (in predefined percentages) between the national Treasury and the regions, provinces and districts in which mining operations take place. Some communities consider themselves affected by mines but receive very little by way of increased local government funding.
- When local governments are funded though the mining canon, they are in large part restricted by national policies to spending on particular types of infrastructure investment such as building schools or irrigation. Whilst these projects may be welcomed by local communities, they can exclude the poorest members of communities from any benefits from the contracts to build these projects, and often they do not resolve underlying long-term economic challenges such as dwindling water reserves (which nearby mining can exacerbate), lack of productive agricultural land, and the absence of longer-term paid employment.
- While large scale mines aim to follow international environmental standards, resources available for the oversight of environmental impacts are often lacking. This means that mines tend to be self-policing. Local communities can be left to question the pollution of local water courses or other impacts to crops or health such as traffic pollution or dust created by trucking minerals from mines to processors. Challenging a company on such matters can be highly problematic.
Mining investment fits into a national narrative of ‘progress’, in which mining is seen as the key avenue through which Peru can ‘develop’ or ‘modernise’. Such aspirations fail to put food on plates or pay medical bills. Mining activities need to bring concrete Improvements to the daily life for those affected.
With local communities placed under pressure from both mining and other impacts such as the economic problems caused by Covid-19, they are demanding both a greater share of the fruits of the land (of which minerals are but one) and careful custodianship over the earth.
The recent conflicts and demonstrations form part of this ongoing battle. For poverty-stricken communities, challenging mining companies and government is no small investment in time and resources. Nor is it without risks to people’s lives and freedom. Such actions represent a growing angry shout about a distribution of goods, money and power in which local populations suffer while others reap the rewards.
Recent Comments