The Castillo government is producing some interesting initiatives on the crucial question of the ‘mining tightrope’: how to balance the need to collaborate with large international companies whilst heeding the demands of communities that have long endured abuse and the lack of dialogue at the hands of such companies?
On this, there are interesting initiatives at both the macro and micro levels. At the macro level is the promise of new mining legislation and efforts to explain what is meant by ‘social profitability’. At the micro level, initiatives have been launched that respond to local protests and complaints.
Regarding the macro level, a new Ley General de Minería is in the pipeline, as is a law to support small-scale mining. Iván Merino, the minister of energy and mines, described these in an interview with Rumbo a Perumin. He also flagged a possibility that the PSG will need to follow up: a new law with respect to the ‘canon’. In its present form, the canon law authorises the distribution of 50% of mining profits back to the region and province where mining is carried out. The PSG has criticised on numerous occasions the way this operates. In addition, Merino gave publicity to the building of two planned mining railways: Marcona to Andahuaylas and Cajamarca to Bayóvar.
The concept of ‘social profitability’, as he explained it, will be based on criteria that seek to blend the interests and concerns of the various actors, including the national interest.
The Ministry of the Environment (Minam) has also been active, creating a working group to recommend changes in the rules and procedures determining regulations related to environmental impact.
At the micro or community level, recent examples include Prime Minister Guido Bellido travelling to Saramurillo in Loreto to discuss the blockages by communities of Petroperú’s transport facilities. For example, in Datem del Marañón, a working group has been established to support indigenous peoples there. Such initiatives often build on measures from the Vizcarra government, focusing more on how to implement proposals. A further example is Bellido intervening to meet Asháninka demands. Another is the dialogue table in Espinar, reinstalled after eight months of waiting.
This attention to making measures work is promising, but the other side from introducing such legislation is the competence and commitment of those on the ground to make it work: parallel efforts will be required to support local institutions carry out agreed plans.
So much for the positive side. Where policy has encountered less success concerns issues that have generated tension with the mining industry: the taxation of mining profits and the granting of the social licence, the latter exemplified by the continuing fight over Tía María in Arequipa region.
On taxation, the private sector is digging in its heels. President Pedro Castillo and Economy Minister Pedro Francke have announced their intention to request authorisation from Congress to legislate on tax matters. They want to include changes to mining taxation so as to capture a larger slice of the mining rent, inflated by high prices. The response of the mining companies has been an all-out war against any increase in taxation.
On the social licence issue, Tía María is the reference point. Communities oppose a mining project that would, they say, impact negatively on local farming. This conflict between Southern (SPCC) and communities over property rights and related issues began in 2011 and remains unresolved because of continued opposition from local communities. The government’s reluctance to concede to SPCC is made explicit in a recent interview with Francke.
The positive strategies may – and this is presumably the economic team’s hope – generate the political support needed to sustain policies on taxation and the social licence. But there is still a long way to go.
Recent Comments