Last week the process of choosing a new Constitutional Tribunal (TC) got under way in what promises to be a key factor in the country’s political and institutional stability going forward.

The Congress established a congressional commission to conduct the forthcoming contest to see how six of the seven members of the TC are replaced. Several members of the commission have outstanding investigations by public prosecutors that raise questions as to their probity and impartiality.

As avid readers of the Newsletter will recall, members of the previous Congress failed in their attempts to push through approvals of new TC members prior to the change of government on 28 July. With three of those who appeared best qualified failing to win approval from the two-thirds of Congress required, the whole process had to be aborted. Six of the seven TC members are due to be replaced.

Several commission members face investigative enquiries. They include José María Balcázar, the commission president (Perú Libre) who faces an investigation into illicit earnings in Chiclayo; Jorge Montoya, the retired admiral (Renovación Popular) who faces an accusation of sedition for exhorting people not to recognize the results of the second round of presidential elections; Wilmer Elera (Somos Perú) who faces four charges in Piura; and Eduardo Salhuana (Alianza para el Progreso) who faces three in Madre de Dios.

The 1993 constitution (Articles 201 and 202) lay out the functions of the TC and how it is selected. Among its functions is the duty to adjudicate conflicts over competences of the different branches of the state, including the executive and legislature. It has played a conspicuous role over the last five years as conflicts between these two powers became a perennial of politics.

Such conflicts show no sign of diminishing. The legislative programme of the Castillo government is at the mercy of an opposition which has made clear its intention to harass the new administration from day one.

So, who replaces the six justices due to retire is a critical political issue. Since it behoves the Congress to carry out that selection, their choice will be determinant as to whether the TC acts independently (as it is supposed to) or becomes a tool in the hands of an angry opposition.

With the government proposing to rewrite the constitution on the basis of a constituent assembly, the TC will play a central role in interpreting the current constitution in the face of contentious claims on both sides.

We will be paying close attention in the coming weeks to how the TC selection plays out. The current TC, the majority of whose members should have been replaced two years ago, remains in office until new members are selected.