Peru’s former environment minister, Manuel Pulgar Vidal, last week attacked the country’s lack of concern for environmental issues over recent years, accusing the Kuczynski government in particular of failing to follow through with the initiatives taken that culminated in the Paris accords. He characterised this as “navel gazing” and a preoccupation with extractive investment to the exclusion of other more important concerns.

He says that not only has Peru lost its leadership on environmental matters since COP 21, but he also slates the failure of candidates in the presidential election to even understand the issues raised by environmental policy at the global level. “We don’t seem to have an idea of what’s going on in the world” he said, alluding to the lack of informed debate during the election campaign. The lack of proposals on environmental issues in the presidential debates, he said, had been “shameful”.

Pulgar Vidal makes reference to the often-proclaimed datum that Peru is the third most vulnerable country to climate change, arguing that this reflects its problem of aridity and its demographic makeup with 70% of its population facing potential water shortage. Whereas this remains the case, he says that Peru faces other problems arising from climate change. He cites its effects on the fishing industry, agriculture and the energy matrix.

On the last of these, he refers to what he calls the “gas trap” by which he means Peru’s reliance on natural gas as an energy source providing no incentive to develop alternative sources of energy, whether wind, solar or green hydrogen (as in Chile). The Castillo administration needs to embark urgently on energy transition, he says.

On forestry policy, Pulgar Vidal refers to what he calls “an eternally unfinished policy” in which he thinks that decentralisation has had “catastrophic” effects with regional governments proving to be terrible managers of local resources. He also refers to Peru’s failure to ratify the Escazú accords and the need to overcome denial on this issue.

At the national level he argues for the need for an environment minister who can stand up to those from the various productive sectors and negotiate successfully with other interests. He also stresses the need for a minister of economy and finance who understands the changing global agenda and can link up environmental imperatives with economic needs and those of development more generally. He sees Pedro Francke as someone who understands this.