Without consulting either the communities or the ministries most immediately concerned, Congress passed a law on 22 April enabling the military and police to arm and control self-defence committees. This has major implications for notions of community autonomy.

The law, originally proposed by members of Congress from the Alianza para el Progreso and Fuerza Popular, maintains that the principal role of community self-defence is the support of the armed forces and the police against terrorists, drug traffickers and others. To this end, it posits that weapons are to be supplied by donations from the state or the private sector.

Organisations representing forest peoples (such as AIDESEP), the organisation of rondas campesinas (CUNARC), and the National Agrarian Confederation (CNA), as well as the organisation of indigenous and Amazonian women, said the new law violated existing rights to autonomy and free determination at the community level. They regard it as unconstitutional since it promotes armed bodies controlled by external authorities from outside the communal structure with whom they may be in conflict.

The organisations quote the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s observation in its 2003 report that the so-called Committees for Armed Defence and Rural Development (CADs) were established under pressure and threats from the armed forces. They became a paramilitary force used to combat Sendero Luminoso in the 1980s and 1990s when, on occasions, they were responsible for “crimes that should have been punished”.

The Interior Ministry has commented that this legislation is inconsistent with the rule of law because of the potential risk of arming a form of local police. The Ministry of Defence has argued the law is unviable in generating an overlap with existing community bodies established for self-protection. The Ministry of Justice and Human Rights fears that if the law is promulgated it would create an illicit market for weapons and increase existing levels of violence in areas where assassination of human rights defenders is already common.

President Francisco Sagasti is thus under pressure not to enact the measure. Community groups hope that a different approach will be adopted that strengthens the legal framework for indigenous jurisdiction rather than create a “parallel structure that confronts, weakens and subordinates us to the armed forces”.