On 22 September the Constitutional Tribunal voted four to two to uphold the constitutionality of a resolution that upheld the principle of debts to the SUNAT not being time limited. The Law Association (Colegio de Abogados) in La Libertad region had sought to prevent SUNAT from collecting debts totalling 9.3 billion soles (US$1=3.5 soles) owed by some of Peru’s largest firms. Of these, 26 are claiming that the tax demands were time limited.
The salience of such massive debts to the state comes, of course, at a time when the Covid-19 lockdown has greatly reduced the amount of tax revenue entering the Treasury while significantly increasing public spending on payments to sustain the poor economically. The amounts owing would fund at least two rounds of subsidies to 9 million households.
According to the ruling, those debts should be paid on the time schedule laid down by SUNAT. The Colegio de Abogados had argued that Legislative Decree 1421, dating from 2017, violated the constitution as the state had to determine and collect tax owing within a maximum of four years. They argued that DL 1421 which specified that the time during which tax debts had to be paid exceeded the special faculties under which Congress had delegated legislative faculties to the executive.
Marianella Ledesma, the TC’s president who voted against time limits, said afterwards “these large companies should pay their taxes just like all other tax-payers, with no distinction”.
Many of the companies with large debts to SUNAT come from the mining sector. Heading the list is Buenaventura (2 billion soles) whose president is Roque Benavides, past president of Confiep. Others include Antapaccay (728 million soles), Las Bambas (698 million), Cerro Verde (542 million), Volcan (161 million) and Antamina (119 million). The list also includes construction companies under investigation within Lava Jato, including Graña y Montero (62 million soles), Odebrecht (62 million) and Queiroz Galvão ((1 million). Others include Telefónica (359 million), Latam Airlines (351 million) and Scotiabank (1.1 billion),
The seventh member of the TC, who did not take part in the session, was José Luis Sardón whose brother works for Scotiabank and who therefore was deemed to have a conflict of interest.
The decision of the TC is final and cannot be appealed.
Recent Comments