No sooner had the Congress failed to achieve the removal of President Martín Vizcarra from office than it sought to pursue its next move in its drawn out battle with the executive: to appoint new members of the Constitutional Tribunal who will toe the line.
On 22 September, members of a special congressional committee announced ‘fast-track’ procedures that would speed up the election of five new members of the seven-person tribunal whose terms formally expired some time ago but whose replacements it falls, constitutionally, to Congress to select.
The commission, presided over by Rolando Ruiz (Acción Popular), rejected the idea that specialist advice should be listened to before pushing ahead with an election. The next step will be to seek public support for the ‘fast track’ procedure.
In its ruling on Vizcarra the previous week, the Tribunal adopted the decision to look into the constitutional grounds on which a president may be removed for what Article 113 of the constitution terms “permanent moral incapacity”. Readers will recall that this was the ground that members of Congress used when they sought to expel Vizcarra over his alleged role in the so-called ‘Swing’ affair.
For some constitutional lawyers, it would be incorrect to push ahead with choosing a new majority on the Tribunal while this case remains unresolved. Beatriz Ramírez, quoted in La República, believes that the Congress would be seen to harbour a political bias in fulfilling its constitutional responsibilities. “This would damage the principle of impartiality and the appearance of impartiality that they [those members of Congress] should have in carrying out their choice”, she says.
In a similar vein, the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL) says that the selection of new members of the Constitutional Tribunal should only be carried out by the Congress that is elected next April. It sees the attempt to remove Vizcarra as creating a situation in which the procedure had become “highly politicised”. Further, it is critical of the lack of transparency surrounding the decision of the special commission.
Readers will also recall that it was the attempt to impose a new leadership on the Tribunal that finally led last September to the dissolution of Congress.
The Tribunal plays a key role in Peru’s constitutional affairs as the arbiter of disputes as to what is constitutional and what is not. Article 201 of the 1993 constitution highlights its quality as “independent and autonomous”. Its seven members are elected for a period of five years and cannot be re-elected. However, they are allowed to continue in office until such time as they have been properly replaced.
Recent Comments