A report analysing the implementation of ILO Convention 169 (Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989) by the Peruvian government has been released. A large number of Peruvian indigenous organizations have been involved in this, with support from the Coordinadora Nacional’s Working Group on Indigenous Peoples. Through case examples, the report analyses in detail a number of shortcomings, showing how the Peruvian government has failed to live up to its international commitments to adhere to the protection of the social, economic and cultural rights of indigenous peoples while respecting their identity, customs and institutions. It identifies recommendations under each subject heading which indigenous organizations consider essential for the full realisation of their rights.

Convention 169 came into force in Peru in 1995. Twenty-one years on, gaps remain between Peru’s international obligations and practice on the ground. Issues covered in the report include: the criminalization of social protest, the situation of indigenous women, indigenous rights to intercultural health and education, and the relationship between indigenous identity and climate change.

The report also covers in detail issues of legal recognition of their territories (on the basis of land titling) and the need to rationalise land tenure (ordenamiento territorial). Far from guaranteeing indigenous communities legal rights to their territories, the report affirms that since 2013 the government has passed legislation that leaves communities vulnerable to land being taken from them in order to promote economic growth by the removal of so-called bureaucratic barriers (‘tramitologia’) to facilitate investment (see PSG article).

A key concern is the obligation on government to ensure that indigenous communities are consulted on decisions that can severely affect their livelihoods. Through case examples, the report examines the limitations to date to the effective implementation of the Ley de Consulta, in force since 2011. Up to September 2015, there had been 27 consultations. Of these, 14 have been completed (ten in the oil sector, two on the creation of protected natural areas, and two in relation to the implementation of detailed regulations to the Ley Forestal). However, only two of these consultation processes have been officially concluded.

To date, only one consultation process has reportedly begun in the mining sector, the Aurora project, for which preliminary negotiations started last October. It is still too early, however, to know what progress and results have been achieved. It also remains unclear the extent to which consultation will be applied more generally to the mining sector. According to Daniel Sánchez, the head of the programme of indigenous people at the Defensoría del Pueblo, “in 2014 fourteen mining projects were approved without the affected communities being consulted. Nine of these were taking place in the territories of indigenous communities in the Andean region”. Of these, five were based on denial of the communities’ indigenous identity, an issue now highly contested.

The controversy surrounding ‘consulta’ has been embittered by the failure to publish a final version of the official database of indigenous communities, thereby enabling communities with the right to ‘consulta’ to be clearly identified, particularly in the Andean highlands.

As to the effectiveness of consultations that have taken place, the report highlights some shortcomings in the implementation of the law, including how decisions are taken about which communities are to be included, the information to be presented to them and its clarity for the communities concerned, and the amount of time they are given to study and discuss the documentation provided. In the oil sector, for example, people are offered the supreme decree that just outlines the project, not the contract of a project itself which provides much more detail about the precise activities involved.

http://derechoshumanos.pe/2016/02/informe-alternativo-2015-sobre-el-cumplimiento-del-convenio-169/