On the night of 17 December Benjamín Flores, a Kakataibo indigenous and former municipal employee and active participant in the land titling of the Mariscal Cáceres indigenous community in Ucayali region, was found dead in his hut. The previous week he had received death threats from coca growers who were cultivating the crop on disputed land. And only a few weeks prior to this, Quinto Inuma, an indigenous environmental defender, had been assassinated in the San Martín region.

The following day ORAU, the regional affiliate of the national Amazonian indigenous organisation AIDESEP, issued a communiqué together with FENAKOKA, the representative organisation of the Kakataibo peoples, denouncing Flores’s death as a reprisal for his environmental activism. Flores would thus be the 33rd indigenous leader assassinated since 2013 for defending indigenous lands against invasion, illegal logging, and the illicit drug trade, and the fifth Kakataibo to be assassinated in three years.

The territories of the Kakataibo people have suffered an alarming increase in the number of land invasions and an expansion in the areas dedicated to coca growing and other illegal activities. This appears to be a consequence of government coca eradication efforts in the Vilcacota, Ene and Mantaro valleys.

In their communiqué ORAU and FENAKOKA placed the blame for Flores’s death on the state for its failure to prevent these types of intimidatory and criminal acts and to provide effective protection for threatened environmental defenders on their own lands. They demanded that the state investigate the crime thoroughly, capture and punish those responsible, and guarantee safety for the family members and authorities of the Mariscal Cáceres community.

The Instituto de Bien Común (IBC), which has been assisting the community with land titling, has also demanded that the state ensure justice for the victims and conduct a speedy investigation to ensure that those responsible do not enjoy impunity. It has also demanded effective action to implement the Ministry of Justice’s Protection Mechanism for Rights Defenders.

The killing, and the public reaction to it, is part of a story repeated over and over in recent years in various parts of the Peruvian Amazon. However, it received an unusual twist when a controversial indigenous leader, Washington Bolivar, claimed that Benjamín, his uncle, had not been assassinated but had died from a possible snake bite or other natural cause and that AIDESEP had claimed he was assassinated to ensure its funding from foreign donors.

On 18 December the conservative Lima newspaper Expreso quoted Bolívar as saying: “Our brother Benjamín has not been assassinated by coca growers or any mafia. It was a natural death in his house. That is why we brought him to the morgue, and we are here so that a legal autopsy takes place.” This version was reinforced by the local prosecutor who claimed that signs of frothing at the mouth suggested the possibility of death by snake bite.

Bolívar’s version was publicly rejected by ORAU and FENAKOKA, as well as community leaders. They argued that Bolívar was a fraudulent Kakataibo leader who had been expelled from the community on two occasions for falsifying documents and usurping community leadership in 2020 and 2021. They also denounced him as leader of a campaign to defend the Ocho Sur palm oil company, accused of illegal occupation and deforestation of community territory. Bolivar had been expelled in 2002 for the illegal sale of timber, land trafficking and demanding payments from drug dealers to gain access to communal land.

The lawyer Linda Vigo from the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL), who was present at the autopsy on 19 December, declared that it was impossible to decide with certainty the cause of death because of the deteriorated state of the body. Viga, who is also a member of the Pucallpa Human Rights Commission, stated that the corpse had bruises on the left side of the head and showed signs of bleeding from the nose and mouth.

The forensic doctor responsible for the autopsy said it was not possible to determine the cause of death because of the decayed state of the body. For that reason, it was likely that death had occurred sometime before the discovery of the body. He considered the form and circumstances in which the body was found to be strange.

He claimed that Flores could have been killed by a blow to the head and that there was no sign of a bite by a snake or any other venomous creature. Representatives of the Ministerio Público, the Ombudsman’s office (Defensoría), and the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights were also present.

Miguel Ángel Barrionuevo, representative of the provincial prosecutor’s office, observed that the body did not show signs of violence, such as bullet wounds or other lesions, and supported the snake bite thesis. A person claiming to be Flores’ son denied that the victim had received threats to his life.

The Kakataibo leader, Herlin Odicio, lamented the fact that the prosecutor “was entertaining a hypothesis based on the versions of persons from outside the community”, accusing him of attempting to exonerate the state from blame and seeking to cover up the work of mafias.

Due to the contradictory versions and mutual accusations of those involved, it is not possible to decide with certainty the cause of Flores’s death, and whether his name should be added to the list of assassinated rights defenders. Unfortunately, until an independent third party carries out a thorough investigation, it is unlikely that we will ever know for sure what happened to Benjamín Flores in the days leading up to the discovery of his corpse.