THE ECONOMIC CHALLENGES OF RECOVERY FROM THE COVID-19 CRISIS
Panellists:
Pedro Francke: economist, teacher and researcher at the Universidad Pontificia Católica del Perú;
Humberto Campodónico: engineer, specialising in the economics of the oil industry, teaching in the economics faculty of the Universidad Nacional de San Marcos; and
Ariela Ruiz Caro: economist, analyst at the Americas Program for the Andean Region and research member of the Working Group on Regional Integration and Latin American Unity of CLACSO.
Moderator:
Rosemary Thorp: Vice President of the PSG, Emeritus Reader at Oxford University.
The webinar started with a brief summary of the current situation which has already been covered in webinars 1 and 2, with the second webinar concentrating on the situation in Amazonia. Briefly:
- Mortality rates are among the highest in the world, with more deaths than in the civil conflict in the 1980s.
- IMF estimates in 2020 that there will be a contraction of 15%, the highest in Latin America. Employment was down 40% in April, and then dropped further to 50%.
- Recently electricity usage has started to recover, the excess mortality rate has decreased, and Covid infections in both the Sierra and Selva have markedly decreased.
- However, it is not understood why Covid is decreasing, nor if there will be a second wave.
- Nor is it understood where demand will come from. In particular tourism is unlikely to recover much in 2021.
The panel then turned to the external situation and the possibilities it may give for recovery and came to some relatively optimistic conclusions. The buoyancy of gold, zinc and copper in the international market is helping exports and Peru has a low level of public foreign debt (even though private external debt is high and this may be a vulnerability). However, the tensions between China and the United States are leading to pressures from the Trump Administration that threaten Peru’s sovereignty. For example, there is a new investment programme on offer which is conditional on countries limiting Chinese presence. As noted above, tourism is a sector which has been profoundly affected, and foreign remittances have fallen by 25%.
Domestic policies came in for strong criticism:
- The government has given loans and grants, but most of the money has gone to the larger firms.
- There has been late and only limited support to small-scale agriculture.Social protection amounts to only 2% of GDP – there is a programme for the rural poor but not one addressing urban poverty. Urban poverty in Lima had been just 10%, but now those who had edged into the middle class are falling back into poverty. Poverty overall is expected to increase from 20% to 30%. There are no universal social programmes in Peru. The ‘bono‘ policy (one-off payments to those in need) was slowly and poorly implemented and inadequate in the amount offered. Poverty has worsened dramatically, as has employment.
- Infrastructure projects are talked about but have not yet materialised.
- The Ministry of Finance (MEF) is already wanting to cut spending to consolidate on the fiscal side when there is still room to borrow and stimulate recovery.
- As noted, tourism, which employs 5-6% of the workforce, will not recover quickly.
A major concern in the webinar was the way in which the emphasis on fostering big mining projects has led to unacceptable and dangerous reductions in the efficacy of regulation and the effectiveness of consultation with the communities affected. Among the points made:
- This and previous governments have been making environmental impact assessments easier for companies, limiting consultations with local communities.
- There is very limited scope for reform or changes in legislation before the end of this parliament’s term in July. Hydrocarbons and mining laws are currently not progressing.
- Congress has recently rejected the regional Escazú Agreement, which would have regulated investments in the Amazon, with congress claiming concerns about sovereignty.
- The Environmental Control Entity (OEFA) has postponed collection of fines that it has applied to firms and has charged no interest on theses.
- The government has also postponed the mandatory contribution that firms pay to the regulatory institutions, which makes up two-thirds of their income.
- The government has proposed allowing consultation to take place via electronic platforms, which is inappropriate given lack of internet access, language, and the communities’ right to take collective decisions.
- Damage could be long term to OEFA and to other institutions.
Questions from the audience included renewables policy and the cost of corruption.
Q. On renewables: fossil fuels are a dead end ecologically and economically. What efforts are being made to shift to a renewable energy model?
A. Very little. Renewables only account for 4% of electricity, mostly solar (not including hydro). This is much lower than Brazil, Chile or Argentina which have much larger solar sectors. There is limited government support due to the lobbying power of oil & gas and power companies. Peru does not have a medium- or long-term energy plan; the rules tend to be made by private companies. Peru has natural gas in large quantities, which is a fossil fuel but much less polluting than oil, but this has not gotten off the ground because of technical issues and reliance on private investment when this is really a public good. There is not much sign of things changing on this.
Q. On corruption: are there any estimates of the monetary value of corruption?
A. For large cases such as Odebrecht where ex-presidents have been prosecuted there are figures but it is much harder to estimate lower-level corruption. Known cases amount to some US$8-10bn. This is an area needing further research but there are many conceptual and methodological difficulties.
In the final section we asked: if we want a recovery path that promotes greater equity, protects marginal populations, and strengthens institutions for protection down the line, what should be done first?
We concluded:
- We were relatively optimistic that export-led growth will get going.
- But we fear that this government – and the next – will give too much away in labour rights, social rights, and on the environment in its desire to help the export-led recovery.
- We fear that the opportunity to learn from the Covid-19 crisis and improve on the past will be missed.
- We want to see:
- a serious and sustained effort to tackle corruption;
- an equally serious effort to improve on levels of social protection, in all areas – education, health, infrastructure;
- a major tax reform with a programme to reduce tax evasion;
- a reactivation of demand, especially among the poor and the marginal;
- more effort on local and national value added from extractives, for example, production of fertilizer from phosphates which are currently exported;
- the development of a policy on renewable resources and a wider energy policy, and their implementation. For example, renewable electricity (mostly solar) is only 4%. Natural gas is abundant and much less polluting than oil, but it cannot be easily distributed within the country;
- the bureaucracy of the Peruvian state does not work well and must be improved;
- a re-think of the role of the state, in particular the relationship between the state and the private sector, probably requiring a change in the constitution, which underscores important aspects of this relationship.
This last point was elaborated after the webinar closed and needs to be discussed more fully in the next webinar. The 1993 Constitution made important changes to the 1979 one, profoundly affecting and limiting the role of the state, especially with regard to investment in public services – transport, health, education. Further, the sanctity of contracts introduced in the 1993 version makes it hard to increase taxes on corporates, and the economic chapter provides a poor framework for transparency.
The next two webinars will consider why these sorts of change are so difficult to achieve, and what might help. The next webinar is on Saturday 14 November. Sign up now HERE.
Recent Comments