The Constitutional Tribunal (TC) voted on 18 October on the controversial case that sought to clarify whether the Congress was acting within its powers in intervening on a judicial decision to reinstate two members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ), both perceived by Congress as adversaries. It voted in favour of the judicial branch and against the Congress, although the decision was clouded by some controversy as to whether the TC was quorate at the time.

Constitutional experts claim that the ruling showed a degree of independence on the part of the TC. The majority block in Congress has long been seeking to increase its control over the JNJ. The JNJ plays a crucial role in appointing judges and public prosecutors as well as the heads of two of the three electoral organisations. The two JNJ members whom Congress had sought to dismiss were Aldo Vásquez and Inés Tello.

Prior to the TC ruling, Congress had approved controversial changes by reducing the number of votes required to resolve disputes over constitutional competences from five to four. In the event, four of the seven TC judges ruled in favour of the judiciary although the other three absented themselves during the sitting. The president of the TC has argued that the meeting was indeed quorate.

Lacking the appropriate majority of five (out of its seven members), the TC had previously opted to wait while Congress changed what is known as the Código Procesal Constitucional (CPC). Approval of the reform by Congress thus opened the way for the TC to make a ruling. Observers expected it to rule according to the wishes of the majority block in Congress led by the Fujimorista Fuerza Popular party. However, the move now appears to have backfired with the majority of TC members voting to support the position of the judiciary.

In March, Vargas and Tello were dismissed by the Congress from their posts in the JNJ. Arguing that the reasons for this were spurious, they appealed to the judiciary which restored them to their posts.