Prime Minister Gustavo Adrianzén said on 26 June that the government would send a ‘high level’ team to the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague to challenge charges that President Dina Boluarte was guilty of crimes against humanity. The charges relate to the killing of 49 persons in December 2022 and January 2023 in Andahuaylas, Ayacucho and Juliaca.

The case against Boluarte has been brought by the International Human Rights Federation and by Peru’s Aprodeh. They argue that the killings of unarmed demonstrators resulted from a premediated policy endorsed by Boluarte. Army and police detachments, they say, used disproportionate lethal force to quell the demonstrations about the way Boluarte had assumed presidential powers following the overthrow of former president Pedro Castillo.

The charges brought against Boluarte claim that there “is a reasonable basis to affirm” that the army and police, with the knowledge of top officials in the executive, carried out a “systematic attack” against the civilian population. They allege that the operations were preceded by emergency decrees issued by the president and her cabinet. They say that as well as the 49 persons assassinated, there were at least a further 115 who were the targets of subsequent assassination attempts.

The government hopes that the ICC will refuse the admissibility of the case on the basis that what happened was not a crime against humanity as such. Adrianzén is quoted as saying that it was “an outrage [that] reflected a lack of loyalty to Peru”. He also said that “this is absurd and it reflects deep ignorance [to maintain that] it is about systematic violations of human rights”.

Aprodeh has been one of the leading organisations in seeking legal remedy in Peru for victims of human rights abuse since its foundation in1983.

Whether the case proceeds or not, the airing of human rights violations internationally will draw further criticism of Boluarte and her government’s record. If upheld, it will be the first time that a Peruvian president is submitted to such charges at the ICC. It will reinforce the impression that Peru is a country where human rights are not fully respected.

The role played by the army and police in confronting otherwise peaceful demonstrations in southern Peru was the subject of widespread criticism from international human rights agencies last year including Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR).

The role played by Boluarte in the killings has also been the subject of an investigation by Peru’s public prosecutor. The president has been obliged to give evidence on several occasions, but her responses have tended to be either evasive or showing an unwillingness to respond. A former foreign minister, Miguel Angel Rodríguez, is quoted as saying that “it is to be lamented that the president has not treated this matter with the level of seriousness that it deserves in contesting this wave of allegations”.

The ICC case takes place at the same time as members of Congress from the pro-Fujimori Fuerza Popular, one of the parties that supports Boluarte, are promoting legislation that would effectively provide a blanket amnesty to those responsible – including Fujimori himself and several of his ministers – for human rights crimes committed during the two-decades (1980-2000) of conflict with Sendero Luminoso.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission reported in 2003 how nearly 70,000 people were killed either by Sendero or the armed forces.

The proposed law has been bitterly criticised by the IACHR as overriding crimes against humanity. It argues that Peru only ratified the Statute of Rome in 2002 and that therefore crimes committed before that date are not subject to its provisions.

However, the election of Alberto Borea as a new judge at the Inter-American Court presages a shift to the right in its position. Borea, who was elected by 16 votes, was the candidate proposed by Boluarte. In 2023, he was quoted as saying that the then prime minister, Alberto Otárola was pursuing a policy on human rights “with the necessary firmness”. His election was strongly opposed by Peru’s Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos. The other new judge elected is from Paraguay.